What is Pin in Paste (PiP) Soldering Technology

Pin in Paste smt

Introduction

Pin in paste (PiP) is an advanced soldering technique used in printed circuit board (PCB) assembly. PiPprinting deposits solder paste inside through-hole vias and pads prior to component placement. This enables soldering the through-hole pins and PCB in a single reflow pass. PiP provides benefits over traditional wave soldering or selective soldering methods for through-hole components. This article will provide an in-depth overview of PiP technology, processes, advantages, and implementation considerations.

Overview of Pin in Paste Basics

Pin in paste soldering involves:

  • Depositing solder paste into through-hole PCB locations
  • Mounting components on the solder paste deposits
  • Reflowing to solder component pins and PCB in one step

This contrasts with:

  • First inserting pins through empty holes
  • Then wave or selective soldering the pins

PiP enables efficient all-surface-mount assembly without separate soldering passes.

Why Use Pin in Paste Soldering?

Pin in paste offers several advantages over traditional through-hole soldering:

Lower Cost

Eliminates need for wave soldering or selective soldering equipment. Reduces capital investment.

Higher Reliability

Minimizes thermal shock to components by eliminating second reflow pass. Avoiding multiple passes improves reliability.

Design Flexibility

Enables mixed SMT and through-hole components to be assembled together. Simplifies designs.

Process Simplicity

Only a single solder reflow pass required for all components. Reduces production steps and cycle time.

High Density Capability

Fine pitch PiP printing facilitates dense component placement not achievable with wave soldering.

Improved Quality

Lower defect rates and more consistent joint quality than wave or selective soldering.

Lead-Free Processing

Lead-free solder paste used for PiP is compatible with RoHS regulations.

For these reasons, PiP utilization continues growing for high complexity and low/medium volume assemblies.

PiP Printing Process Overview

Implementing pin in paste soldering involves three main steps:

1. PiP Dispensing

Solder paste is precisely jetted into the through-hole pads and vias prior to component placement.

  • High accuracy paste dispensing machines are used
  • Minimal paste volume is deposited
  • 100% of holes can be printed or only selected locations

2. Component Placement

Components are mounted by pick and place systems onto the solder paste deposits.

  • Paste holds components in place tentatively
  • Some adhesive may still be required in some cases
  • Components do not shift or tilt ideally

3. Reflow

The assembly undergoes reflow soldering to “tent” solder component pins and pads.

  • SAC305 or other solder paste used
  • Same profile as for SMT components
  • May require dual speed profile

This reflows solder to electrically and mechanically connect pins and finalize solder joints.

PiP Processing Considerations

Optimizing PiP print quality and reliability involves attention to:

Paste Deposit Accuracy

Paste must cleanly dispense inside holes without smearing or shifting during placement.

Minimum Paste Volume

Only sufficient solder paste to form the joint should be dispensed to avoid overflow.

Component Pitch Range

Printing can accommodate fine pitch but not ultra-fine component spacing.

Hole Wall Preparation

Oxides inside drill walls may require plasma treatment to enhance wetting.

Solder Mask Expansion

Solder mask overlaps onto pad copper improves capillary flow.

Reflow Profile

Dual speed profiles with extended soak above liquidus often works best.

Careful process engineering is needed to implement PiP effectively.

PiP Design Rules

To enable reliable PiP soldering, PCB designs should follow guidelines:

  • Via Pad Diameters – 0.3mm to 1.0mm range preferred
  • Annular Rings – 0.25mm to 0.5mm annular rings around drilled holes
  • Hole Spacing – No closer than 3x hole diameter side-to-side
  • Copper Plating – โ‰ฅ25ฮผm copper thickness in holes
  • Solder Mask Expansion – 0.05mm to 0.15mm onto pad copper
  • Pad Shapes – Round holes easier than slotted holes

Adhering to these PiP design rules ensures paste can dispense and solder can wick effectively.

PiP Applications

Components suitable for pin in paste soldering include:

  • Through-hole connectors
  • Press-fit pins
  • Transformers, inductors, and coils
  • Switches and relays
  • Terminal blocks and screw terminals
  • Regulators and heat sinks
  • LED displays and indicators

PiP enables mixed SMT/through-hole assemblies combining advanced and legacy components.

Pros and Cons of PiP Technology

Pin in paste offers advantages but isn’t ideal for all situations:

Advantages

  • Lower capital equipment costs
  • Improved joint quality and reliability
  • Design flexibility
  • Lead-free processing
  • High density assembly

Disadvantages

  • Tight process controls required
  • Potential tombstoning without adhesive
  • Additional paste deposit step
  • Fine pitch components challenging
  • Hole wall preparation may be needed

Assemblers should weigh the tradeoffs versus production volumes, cost targets, and product complexity when considering adopting PiP.

The Future of Pin in Paste Soldering

PiP utilization continues growing as dispensing accuracy improves and designs shift towards mixed SMT/through-hole assemblies. Continued progress in solder paste formulation, hole wall surface finishes, and advanced profiling will further expand PiP soldering adoption. Its flexibility and technical capabilities position PiP well for meeting future electronics assembly requirements.

Conclusion

Pin in paste soldering delivers an efficient process for assembling through-hole components without wave or selective soldering equipment. By dispensing solder paste into PCB pads and vias prior to placement, reflow can solder pins and through-holes in one pass. With tight process controls and design considerations, PiP enables high performance mixed technology assemblies. As demand grows for flexible, high-mix production, PiP stands poised to become an increasingly valued assembly process option.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What types of solder paste are used for pin in paste processes?

Standard “no-clean” SAC305 solder pastes are suitable for many PiP applications. For challenging situations, solder pastes engineered specifically for PiP with wider reflow profiles may be preferred.

Q: Does PiP allow double-sided reflow soldering?

Yes, PiP printing can be done on both sides of a PCB followed by double-sided component placement. Dual reflow would then solder all joints in one pass. This further simplifies processing.

Q: How does PiP soldering compare cost-wise to wave soldering?

Eliminating wave soldering equipment provides significant cost savings on lower to medium volume production. For very high volumes, dedicated wave solder may still be more cost effective than PiP bypassing capital expenses.

Q: What are the limitations on component pin pitch with PiP?

The finest pitch achievable with PiP is around 1mm pin spacing depending on hole size. Ultra-fine pitch components may still require traditional soldering approaches.

Q: Can solder paste be dispensed into plated through holes or is plating needed?

PiP printing can work with both plated and non-plated holes. But plating provides stronger metallurgy for soldering. Preparation may be needed on non-plated holes walls.

Pin in Paste (PiP) Technology in SMT Assembly:

We all know the increasing technological advancement in electronics industry, the core reason for which is the growing competition among PCB manufacturers and suppliers. Every PCB CEM (Contract Electronic Manufacturer) is find new ways to cut cost, increase quality and shorten the lead time of PCBs fabrication, assembly, testing and delivery. So talking about the cutting the cost is a highly significant in increasing profit gains and thus ultimately leading the particular CEM in the race of PCB manufacturing competitors.

There are many ways to reduce the manufacturing cost of PCB fabrication and assembly like PCBs with multiple layers are mostly High Density Interconnect (HDI) PCBs, so they are expensive as compared to single or double layer PCBs, so in order to compare the cost analysis of PCB manufacturing, it is important to consider two PCBs with same parameters like they both should be multilayer, HDI and SMT + THT components based. However the difference making aspect in terms of cost analysis are the 1- Surface Finish methods 2- PCB components selection 3- Component Sourcing 4- Process cost 5- Labor Cost and 6- Overhead expenses can determine the ultimate cost per PCB that is produced by CEM.

In this article we will discuss the most powerful method of component mounting in prototype PCB assembly process that will ultimately reduce the cost of manufacturing and speed up the process thus resulting in less lead time.

Comparison of Commonly Practiced SMT/THT PCBA and PiP:

YouTube video

While the most of the PCB manufactures and assemblers use the reflow soldering method for SMT (Surface Mount Technology) components assembly and then manual soldering or wave soldering of THT (Through Hole Technology) components, the best method to carry out is the PiP (Pin in Paste) method. The following flow chart shows the common process flow of SMT and THT components assembly.

SMT and THT components assembly

Now in contrast to the above process flow, the PiP (Pin in Paste) PCBA process flow is lot simpler and easier. Checkout the below mentioned PiP process flow chart.

PiP (Pin in Paste) PCBA process flow

As you can see that the process is shortened tremendously, this is because the SMT and Through-hole components are baked by the same Reflow Oven that was used to bake only SMT parts. The PiP process is simplified in following manner.

  • 1- The additional process of manual assembly of THT electronic components is eliminated
  • 2- Wave Soldering is not required
  • 3- Additional PCB Assembly process setup machine i.e. Wave soldering machine is not required
  • 4- Additional labor not required to work on PCB coming out of vacuum reflow oven

Advantages of PiP:

  • 1- Elimination of capital equipment like wave soldering machine, laser soldering machines or any other equipment associated with Through hole soldering
  • 2- Saving labor cost by eliminating hand soldering and labor associated with wave soldering process
  • 3- Cost can be saved by reclaiming floor space used in the wave and hand soldering processes.
  • 4- Material cost saving like solder bars, fluxes, wave solder pallets and other hazardous materials in the wave solder process.
  • 5- Other indirect incentives lesser number of through-hole connection by replacing THT components to their equivalent SMT and reduction in heating operations. Because various stages of heating cycle like reflow, wave or hand soldering can increase the risk of damage to the board and component, hence eliminating the wave and hand soldering methods in PiP is a big benefit.
  • 6- The greatest advantage of PiP is the ability to design PCB with complex components on bottom side, in traditional process most complex components can only be placed on top side of PCB because they are not able to pass through the wave solder process. By eliminating the wave solder process the PCBs can be designed with complex components on both top and bottom side. This makes it easy to design smaller and denser PCBs for smaller electronic devices

So what is actually PiP technology..?

As we know that the Through-Hole components are those that have pins/leads and they need to be inserted into the PCB holes and then soldered manually or by wave soldering machine. A technology that was first used in 1985 by Motorola to solder the THT components in reflow soldering oven and that made strong joints though.

In the pin-and-paste technology, also known as THR (= Through-Hole-Reflow) technology leaded components (THT) are soldered in the reflow process. Paste is printed by means of stencils or dispenser into the through holes for the pins and the through-hole components are assembled on the board. The Pin in Paste PiP is also known as intrusive reflow, Reflow on through hole (ROT), Solder paste on Through Hole technology (SPOTT) and Alternative assembly and reflow technology (AART).

How is PiP Done.?

First of all, the circuit board is printed with solder paste in stencil printer. The stencil printer apply the solder paste on all SMT and THT components locations. Then it may pass through the dispenser for manual dispensing of solder paste, then the SMT and THT components are placed on PCB by means of pick and place robot. After this the whole assembly is placed in vacuum reflow soldering oven, where the solder paste is melted and SMT plus THT components are soldered on PCB. This seems a lot simpler process flow but it can have several challenges which are mentioned below.

Usually the manual hand driven solder paste dispenser is suitable for prototype PCB assembly process where larger production run of PCB is not the case. An example of solder paste dispenser syringe is shown in figure. In the prototyping case, the manual components handling/placement on PCB is recommended.

solder paste dispenser syringe
PCBA

A solder paste stencil example is shown in the figure below

A solder paste stencil example

Challenges of PiP PCBA Technology:

  • 1- The through hole THT and SMT surface mount components are needed to be baked in Reflow oven hence they (whole component including terminal and plastic body i.e. casing) must have capability to withstand high temperature like 260OC for 10 seconds.
  • 2- Because some THT components do not have their equivalent SMT versions so those THT components have to be assembled on PCB and cannot be avoided.
  • 3- The THT component should be selected such that its housing/casing construction allow a visual inspection of the solder joint.
  • 4- A protective stand-off pad beneath the componentโ€™s casing/body must be placed to ensure there is no touching/contact with the solder paste during reflow process.
  • 5- The high speed automated pick and place robot can grab the THT and SMT component from its planar surface to place it on PCB.
  • 6- It can be difficult to provide an adequate solder paste for through hole joints with stencil printing process.

These challenges can be covered by properly focusing on the requirements of Pin in Paste PCB assembly. Some of them are discussed here.

Component Requirement:

  • 1- The component SMT or THT selected for PiP must survive the high temperature of reflow oven
  • 2- The THT components must be selected in a way that it fits the requirements of SMT pick and place robot machine, to be picked and placed on PCB automatically and accurately. These requirements are the component height, component shape and spacing between component pins.
  • 3- The layer of tin must be coated on top of vias for THR (Through Hole Reflow), hence to achieve this, the minimum distance between component and PCB should be between 0.3mm to 0.7mm and the THT component lead should be 1.5mm thicker than the PCB thickness in order to meet IPC3 standard.

Component Pad Requirements:

  • 1- It is recommended that the smaller components placed on bottom side and larger components on top side. A minimum of 2mm spacing must be kept around PIP components; if there are multiple PIP components then at-least 10mm spacing between adjacent PiP components must be ensured to avoid interference during automatic mounting by Pick and place robot.
  • 2- The distance between adjacent through hole centers should be at least 2mm, distance between edges of adjacent pads should be at least 0.6mm, distance between pad edge and aperture diameter should be at least 0.3mm. Pad aperture diameter should be larger than component pin diameter by 0.2 to 0.4mm. This is done to avoid tin connection between adjacent pins or between pads.

Stencil Requirements:

  • 1- The most important parameter for stronger solder joint is the amount/volume of solder paste being printed by stencil, this is governed by diameter of through holes, thickness of substrate and lead shape. The tin paste must fill the electroplated through hole and fillets are on the top and bottom of PCB.
  • 2- The amount of tin paste required by THT solder joints is larger than the required by SMT
  • 3- Usually the flux fills the 50% of the volume of plated through-hole and remaining 50% is filled by tin paste, hence air bubbles or voids can form when the flux is volatized after soldering process. This can be troublesome, so suitable amount of solder/tin paste must be applied on each through-hole pad.
  • 4- The ideal tin paste filling must be greater than 90% and tin paste filling amount in through holes must be greater than bottom pad by 0.5 to 1mm. A squeegee angle of 45Ois reasonable however the smaller the squeegee angle the more then tin paste is filled in the through hole and greater the angle the lesser the tin paste fill in through hole as show in diagram below where V velocity is constant in both cases.
Relationship between Printing Angle and Tin Paste Filling Amount

Reflow Oven Requirements:

  • The reflow oven temperature settings allow the smooth and steady heat transmission through radiation to the solder pads of SMT and solder joints of THT. As can be seen from the typical reflow temperature profile, the liquidus is at 217OC for 45-75 seconds. This is actually the reflow window, however the slow ramp of 1-3OC is important for stable temperature rise and then degrading the temperature uniformly at the rate of 2-4OC finishes of the reflow process.
slow ramp of 1-3OC

Conclusion:

Summing it up all, we can say that PiP (Pin in Paste) method of PCB assembly is extraordinarily useful for mass production of smaller, denser and lighter PCBAs which can cut the cost of production tremendously. With Pin in Paste technology one can have a stronger and better THT solder joint as that of manual or wave soldering and can place complex SMT components on both sides of PCB thus optimizing PCB board space and miniaturizing electronic devices.

Step by Step to Manufacture CCL By Epoxy Resin in Circuit board

fr4 Epoxy Resin

Introduction

Copper clad laminate (CCL) forms the basic structure of printed circuit boards. CCL consists of a central insulating core material sandwiched between layers of copper foil. The manufacturing process to create quality CCL utilizing epoxy resin involves multiple steps including impregnation, lamination, copper bonding, and final finishing. This article will overview the end-to-end CCL production process using epoxy resin chemistry.

Overview of CCL with Epoxy Resin

CCL material consists of:

  • Central insulating dielectric core
  • Layer of copper foil on each side
  • Epoxy resin throughout core

The core provides mechanical support. Epoxy resin gives chemical adhesion and bond integrity. Copper foil enables circuit patterning.

Epoxy resin CCL offers:

  • High bond strength
  • Good thermal performance
  • Excellent chemical resistance
  • Long-term reliability
  • Cost effective manufacturing

Epoxy resins are the most common resin system used in PCB materials.

CCL Manufacturing Steps

Producing quality CCL with epoxy resin involves the following key steps:

1. Core Material Preparation

The insulating core material comes in sheets consisting of woven fiberglass cloth. The material is inspected, cleaned, batched, and staged for impregnation.

2. Resin Mixing

Liquid epoxy resin is weighed and mixed with hardeners and other reactive additives to form the impregnation resin. The mix is filtered for cleanliness.

3. Impregnation

The core material is pulled through a tank of prepared resin. The woven glass cloth fully wets out as resin penetrates evenly throughout each sheet. This stage determines final resin content.

4. B-Stage Oven Curing

The impregnated core material is pulled through a long heated tunnel oven. Heat causes partial curing of the resin into a tacky B-stage state ready for lamination.

5. Copper Foil Bonding

Rolls of thin copper foil are pressed onto both sides of the impregnated, B-stage core material. The assembly then enters a heated nip roller press.

6. Autoclave Lamination

The copper clad sheet enters an autoclave chamber. High pressure and heat fully cures the resin bonding the foil to the core into a solid laminate.

7. Cooling

After autoclave curing, the laminate passes through a cooling zone to bring CCL temperature back down for additional processing.

8. Roller Treatment

Roller presses apply mechanical pressure to ensure lamination uniformity, remove any air pockets, and improve surface smoothness.

9. Machining

Computer numeric control (CNC) routers machine the CCL into standardized sheet sizes with beveled edges. Holes may also be drilled.

10. Quality Inspection

100% inspection of CCL sheets checks for defects, thickness, hole quality, and other metrics to ensure specifications are met.

11. Packaging

Inspected sheets are carefully packaged to avoid damage prior to shipment or further PCB processing.

The CCL sheets must meet exacting standards to endure PCB fabrication, assembly, and service life. Strict process controls provide consistent, high-quality CCL product.

Key Process Considerations

Several factors are critical during CCL manufacture:

Resin Content

The amount of resin solids impregnated into the woven glass must stay within a target range. Too much or too little resin impacts properties.

No Voids

Air pockets between glass fibers or delaminations create weak points that can cause PCB failures.

Controlled Thickness

Consistent core thickness is critical across each CCL lot. Thickness uniformity impacts subsequent PCB processes.

Bond Integrity

Strong, uniform bonds between resin, foil, and glass withstand PCB processing stresses and temperature cycling.

Dimensional Stability

Sheets must exhibit minimal curling or shrinking to avoid registration issues during PCB imaging and etching.

Cleanliness

No residue or foreign material can remain on surfaces or in the core to prevent PCB defects.

Maintaining strict tolerances and disciplines for these parameters ensures reliable CCL quality.

Material Options

Various material options exist when formulating CCL with epoxy resin:

Epoxy Chemistry

  • Standard Bisphenol A epoxy
  • High Tg epoxy for improved thermal capability
  • Halogen-free epoxy for environmental compliance
  • Low Dk epoxies to reduce signal loss

Core Material

  • Standard E-glass with greater resin absorption
  • Quartz glass that absorbs less resin
  • Non-woven aramid or polyester fibers

Copper Foil

  • Standard ED copper
  • Rolled annealed copper for high ductility
  • Low profile copper foils

Coatings – Treatments can be applied to finished CCL sheets:

  • Oxide surface treatments to improve resin bonding
  • Graphite coatings to reduce drilling debris

The choices result in application-specific CCL material optimized for electrical, thermal, and mechanical needs.

Quality Control Testing

fr4-3mm-PCB

To validate material performance, CCL undergoes extensive quality control testing at multiple stages:

  • Interlaminar Bond Testing – Measures resin-to-foil peel strength
  • Microsection Analysis – Checks layer uniformity under magnification
  • Thermal Stress Testing – Evaluates degradation under temperature cycling
  • Fabrication Simulation – Test drilling, imaging, and etching on samples
  • Dielectric Analysis – Determines dielectric constant and loss tangent
  • Dimensional Stability Analysis – Quantifies shrinkage and expansion
  • Electrical Testing – Verifies dielectric breakdown voltage

Statistical process control with extensive testing provides the assurance of product quality and consistency.

Conclusion

Manufacturing reliable copper clad laminate utilizing epoxy resin requires careful process control and validation. When executed properly, CCL provides the robust foundation needed for further PCB fabrication and assembly into quality electronic products. The combination of high performance resins, sturdy core materials, and advanced manufacturing techniques enables CCL to serve its vital role in the production of printed circuit boards.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why is fiberglass most commonly used as the core material in CCL?

Fiberglass provides an optimal balance of mechanical strength, dimensional stability across temperature variations, dielectric performance, and cost-effectiveness. The woven glass cloth construction also absorbs resin effectively during impregnation.

Q: What are some key advantages of epoxy resin systems?

Epoxy resins offer high adhesive strength, chemical and moisture resistance, good dielectric properties, processing versatility, and cost efficiency. These characteristics make epoxies ideal for electrical applications.

Q: What is the difference between FR-4 and other common CCL designations?

FR-4 is a specific flame-retardant grade of CCL made from brominated epoxy resin and E-glass core. Other grades like G-10 and FR-5 indicate different resin systems, core materials, and characteristics optimized for specific applications.

Q: How does CCL thickness tolerance impact PCB manufacturing?

Consistent CCL thickness is critical for maintaining registration during layer-to-layer imaging and etching processes in PCB fabrication. Tighter thickness tolerances enable higher density PCB technologies.

Q: What is the purpose of beveled edges on CCL sheets?

Beveled edges prevent sharp corners from damaging handling equipment or operators. The angled edges also help avoid peeling or lifting during inner layer lamination in multilayer PCB fabrication.

How to Design a BGA?

ball grid array

Introduction

1- Non Solder Mask Defined (NSMD) Landing Pad
Number of Channels

Ball grid array (BGA) packages have become a mainstay of modern electronics, offering high density interconnection in a small footprint. But properly laying out a printed circuit board for a BGA device does require special considerations versus other package styles. This article will provide guidance on key factors when designing BGAs including pad dimensions, placement, routing, thermal design, and board-level reliability. Following these PCB design recommendations will help ensure successful implementation of BGA packages.

Overview of BGA Packages

YouTube video

First, a quick overview of BGA technology:

  • Package surface mounts to PCB via an array of solder balls
  • Ball pitch ranges from 0.5mm to over 1.5mm
  • High density interconnection – Over 1,000 pads/balls
  • Package sizes from 5x5mm up to 55x55mm or larger
  • Lower inductance versus wire bonding
  • Relatively low profile package
  • Common for FPGAs, ASICs, GPUs, large microprocessors

The main PCB design challenges include pad layout, escape routing, and thermal management.

PCB Pad Design

 the typical gradual decrease in pitch from 1.5mm to 0.3mm

The pad design on the PCB mating surface is critical for reliability. Considerations include:

Pad Size

Pad diameters range from 0.20mm to 0.30mm larger than ball diameter. Larger balls need more solder volume and fillet height.

Pad Stencil Design

Stencil openings are typically 0.05mm smaller than pads to optimize solder application. Avoid excess solder volume.

Solder Mask Defined vs Non-Solder Mask Defined

Solder mask defined (SMD) pads reduce solder bridging risks. Non-solder mask defined (NSMD) pads improve self-alignment during reflow.

Anti-Pad Size

Anti-pads surround pads where solder mask is pulled away. Make anti-pads 0.05-0.10mm larger than pads for adequate solder mask web to avoid bridging.

Copper finishes

Immersion silver or ENIG are common final finishes for BGA pads. Avoid HASL for fine pitch BGAs.

Thermal Pad Design

Comparison of BGA and QFP Packages

Larger BGAs often have a solid central thermal pad on the package underside:

  • Provides primary thermal path into PCB
  • Often requires thermal vias under pad into ground plane
  • Use continuous copper fill for maximum heat transfer
  • May require solder mask openings for paste application

Follow all package recommendations for thermal pad design and soldering process.

BGA Placement

LQFP100, 14 x 14 mm 100-pin low-profile quad flat package outline, 0.5mm pitch

BGA placement significantly impacts PCB routing complexity:

  • Central locations simplify routing to all quadrants
  • Near board edges complicates routing
  • Critical signals may warrant inner locations
  • High speed I/O aligned with specific stackup layers
  • Assign IO to ease high-density routing

Place BGAs early before surrounding component placement restricts options.

Thermal Analysis

Confirm sufficient cooling of each BGA during temperature analysis:

  • Ensure rated temperature range is not exceeded
  • Check for temperature gradients across package
  • Leverage thermal vias under pads if needed
  • Incorporate recommended thermal pad soldering process
  • Force air cooling may be required in some cases

BGAs often require careful thermal design due to concentrated heat generation.

Fan-Out Routing

Escape routing from dense BGA pads can be challenging:

  • Stagger rows when possible to ease fan-out
  • Plan pad/ball assignments to optimize flow
  • Via-in-pad on the package or PCB may be needed
  • Match I/O signals to appropriate stackup layers
  • Utilize vias and relief cutouts under BGA to ease congestion
  • Use wider routing traces exiting pads then neck down
  • Allow sufficient routing channels surrounding BGA

Test routing critical nets before finalizing BGA footprint placement.

High Speed Design

Treat BGAs as fixed points when designing impedance controlled routes:

  • Minimize length of high-speed signals near BGA
  • Place BGA to ease same-layer routing of critical signals
  • Identify return paths under device footprint in stackup
  • Provide shielding traces or ground fills around signals
  • Contain high speed routes within component quadrant if possible

BGAs warrant careful signal integrity analysis given their fixed interconnect.

Board-Level Reliability

Several factors impact the long-term solder joint reliability of BGAs:

  • Coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) mismatch
  • Warpage and coplanarity
  • Solder volumes and fillet height
  • Solder joint fatigue over thermal cycles
  • Moisture ingression leading to fractures
  • Pad cratering during thermal excursions

Consult the device datasheet and application notes for recommended design rules and process guidance to enhance BGA reliability.

Design for Manufacturing

Coordinate with your assembly vendor when optimizing BGA design:

  • Specify qualified solder paste & reflow profile
  • Require automated optical inspection after placement
  • Perform X-ray inspection of solder joints
  • Implement thermal relieving processes if needed
  • Apply conformal coating for moisture prevention
  • Utilize underfill material if available for package
  • Qualify process together before full production

Design, assembly process, and materials selection all contribute to robust BGA solder connections and field reliability.

Design Review Guidelines

 reducing the trace and space size

When reviewing a BGA design, consider the following checkpoints:

  • Pad dimensions match datasheet recommendations
  • Solder mask expansion follows IPC guidelines
  • Stencil design enables optimum solder volume per IPC
  • Thermal pad design facilitates effective heat transfer
  • Thermal analysis confirms temperature ranges
  • Placement allows required routing channels
  • Impedance control implemented for high speed routes
  • Fan-out routing uses vias, traces, layers effectively
  • DFM guidelines adhered to aid manufacturability
  • Reliability rules and recommendations followed

Thoroughly vetting the design avoids integration or production issues down the line.

Conclusion

 two ways of placing via capture pads

Designing a PCB for a ball grid array device involves special considerations for routing, thermal management, manufacturability, and reliability. Following IPC guidelines and package-specific recommendations helps ensure your BGA implementation meets performance and quality standards. While requiring more planning, close collaboration between designer and manufacturer enables successfully deploying BGAs and gaining the benefits of the high-density interconnect technology in your products.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How fine of a pitch is achievable with newer BGA packages?

A: Packaging advances are enabling finer BGA pitches below 1mm, including 0.8mm and 0.65mm. This provides interconnect densities over 2500 pads/balls. However, PCB fabrication and assembly requires tighter tolerances at finer pitches which can increase cost.

Q: What are common solder ball materials used with BGA packages?

A: Solder ball alloys are typically eutectic SnAgCu (SAC). High lead solder is still used for some applications requiring high reliability. Lead-free solders are becoming standard due to regulatory pressures to eliminate lead.

Q: What are indications of potential BGA solder joint defects?

A: Excessive voids in solder joints, pad cratering, non-uniform or missing solder fillets, solder bridging, thermal pad dry joints, and cracked joints are defects that can lead to failures. X-ray inspection after assembly is recommended to identify issues.

Q: How many PCB layers are typically required for complex BGA designs?

A: High density BGA designs often require at least 6 to 8 layers. Critical signals need routing on inner layers with reference planes above and below. More layers provides additional routing channels to relieve congestion under devices.

Q: What are common causes of solder joint failures in BGA packages?

A: Thermal expansion mismatch, mechanical stresses, vibration, solder voids, dry joints, poor pad design, and moisture absorption can all contribute to eventual BGA solder joint failure over temperature cycling in the field. Following reliability design rules helps mitigate risks.

BGA PitchLayoutFormula
1.00 mmIn Linea +c + d <=0.53mm
1.00 mmDiagonala +c + d <=0.94mm
0.8 mmIn Linea +c + d <=0.46mm
0.8 mmDiagonala +c + d <=0.68mm

Top 10 Best PCB Design Tools

pcb design tips

Introduction

Printed circuit board (PCB) design is a complex process involving schematic capture, board layout, auto-routing, design rule checks, signal and power integrity analysis, thermal analysis, and much more. With products becoming more advanced, PCB designers need electronic design automation (EDA) tools that can handle rising complexity while improving productivity. This article will review ten leading PCB design software platforms available today based on features, capabilities, and ease-of-use.

Overview of PCB Design Flow

Before diving into the tools, let’s briefly summarize the typical PCB design flow supported by EDA tools:

  • Schematic capture – Draw the electronic schematic showing components and their electrical connections.
  • Symbol creation – Make symbols to represent components on the schematic.
  • Component footprint creation – Generate physical footprints for PCB layout.
  • Netlist generation – Convert schematic into netlist file for PCB layout.
  • Board layout – Arrange footprints and route traces on the PCB canvas.
  • Design rule checking – Validate clearances, spacing, etc. per constraints.
  • Simulation and analysis – Perform signal, power, thermal analysis.
  • Library management – Store and share schematic symbols and footprints .
  • Manufacturing outputs – Generate Gerber, drill, and other manufacturing files.

Now let’s look at 10 excellent PCB design tool options on the market today.

1. Altium Designer

Altium Designer is widely considered the most advanced and complete PCB design system available. It’s loaded with features spanning the entire design process from schematic capture to manufacturing outputs.

Key Features:

  • Unified design environment
  • Interactive routing with real-time DRC
  • Industry leading schematic tools
  • Powerful PCB layout technology
  • Native 3D PCB visualization
  • Flexible design reuse and automation
  • Extensive component library ecosystem
  • Tight manufacturer ecosystem integration
  • Scripting and programming for complex workflows
  • Scalable on-premise or cloud deployment

With unique innovations like ActiveRoute automated routing, Altium provides sophisticated capabilities that enhance designer productivity and workflow.

2. Cadence Allegro

Cadence Allegro offers a complete scalable PCB design environment targeted at high performance electronic applications. It contains advanced capabilities tailored for high speed design.

Key Features:

  • Robust design planning and process management
  • Constraint-driven design flow
  • Proprietary physical routing engine
  • Timing-driven layout tools
  • Extensive visualization capabilities
  • Flexible schematic editing tools
  • Interoperability with multiple analysis tools
  • library creation and management
  • Manufacturing output automation

Allegro provides high speed design capabilities critical for technologies like PCIe, Serdes, and DDR.

3. Mentor Graphics Xpedition

Mentor Graphics Xpedition enables enterprise-level PCB design addressing advanced users to casual occasional users. It is customizable and integrates with DFM tools for manufacturability.

Key Features:

  • High speed design features
  • Unified design environment
  • Manufacturing preparation automation
  • Custom reporting capabilities
  • Integrated library management
  • Scripting and automation
  • Multi-user collaboration
  • Interfaces to MCAD tools
  • DFx design guidance
  • Integrated PLM support

Xpedition balances high performance design capabilities with accessibility for a range of users.

4. OrCAD PCB Designer

orcad PCB
orcad PCB

OrCAD PCB Designer provides a full PCB design workflow with specialized options for high speed, high density, and flex/rigid-flex boards. It offers advanced productivity features.

Key Features:

  • Constraint-driven, synchronized design flow
  • Interactive routing engine
  • Customizable DFM analysis
  • Real-time design feedback
  • Extensive component library ecosystem
  • High speed, signal, and power integrity analysis
  • Team collaboration capabilities
  • Custom reporting and scripting
  • Manufacturing output automation

OrCAD balances features and usability for cost-effective, capable PCB design. It integrates well across the entire electronics workflow.

5. Zuken CR-8000

Show Image

Zuken CR-8000 is a proven PCB design solution for surface mount and complex multilayer boards. It features multi-board assembly and 3D packaging capabilities.

Key Features:

  • High speed design capabilities
  • Constraint manager for controlled flows
  • Multi-board assembly design
  • Photorealistic 3D visualization
  • Flexible layout editing tools
  • DFM analysis and verification
  • Library creation and custom reporting
  • Manufacturing documentation automation
  • Interfaces with MCAD tools

CR-8000 balances functionality with ease of adoption for seamless PCB design. The 3D packaging design environment helps streamline the electronics workflow.

6. Pulsonix PCB Design

Pulsonix PCB Design is an intuitive, easy to adopt platform with excellent usability. It offers advanced functionality like design reuse, manufacturing automation, and interactive routing suitable for many applications.

Key Features:

  • Streamlined, unified interface
  • Constraints manager for correctness
  • Concurrent multi-layer routing
  • Intelligent schematic navigation
  • Integrated 3D viewer
  • Extensive library management
  • Design reuse and block creation
  • Customizable reporting
  • Scripting interface for automation
  • Team collaboration capabilities

Pulsonix offers superb usability without sacrificing capable performance for mainstream PCB applications.

7. Autodesk EAGLE

autodesk-pcb

Autodesk EAGLE is known for affordability combined with powerful features. Different pricing tiers allow customization for hobbyists, startups, and advanced users.

Key Features:

  • Easy to learn user interface
  • Extensive component libraries
  • Real-time DRC during routing
  • XML data exchange capabilities
  • Custom scripting and user language programs (ULPs)
  • Mixed-signal schematic and layout
  • Multi-sheet schematics
  • Integrated version control
  • Third party integrations via APIs

EAGLE continues gaining mainstream share given its balance of ease-of-use and capability at reasonable cost.

8. Pads Professional

Pads Professional enables concept through production PCB design with powerful automation and reuse capabilities.

Key Features:

  • Rules and constraint-driven flow
  • Interactive routing engine
  • Sketch routing capabilities
  • Intelligent component placement
  • Integrated MCAD collaboration
  • Automated manufacturing documentation
  • Role-based design collaboration
  • Programmable automation interface
  • Packaged part reuse and automation
  • Library lifecycle management

PADS leverages automation and customization for efficient PCB design tailored to specific user needs and applications.

9. Solidworks PCB

Solidworks PCB provides a single integrated environment to support the entire electronic development process including MCAD collaboration.

Key Features:

  • Multi-board assembly design
  • Constraint-driven, synchronized workflow
  • Real-time DRC during layout
  • Integrated ECAD/MCAD component reuse
  • Automated manufacturing documentation
  • Design reuse and automation
  • Revision control and design history
  • Custom library development
  • Programmatic automation interface
  • Team collaboration capabilities

Solidworks PCB tightly couples the electronic and mechanical design workflows for streamlined product development.

10. Altium Concord Pro

pcb-creation-software

Altium Concord Pro provides cloud-based PCB design capabilities accessible from any browser. It’s ideal for global team collaboration.

Key Features:

  • Cloud-based design environment
  • Managed component libraries
  • Interactive routing engine
  • Real-time design rule checking
  • Unlimited file storage and history
  • Automated outputs and documentation
  • Seamless team collaboration
  • Task management and notifications
  • Custom reporting and visualizations
  • Role-based access control
  • Dashboards and analytics

For organizations seeking a cloud-based PCB design platform, Altium Concord Pro is purpose-built for the task.

Conclusion

This lineup of leading PCB EDA tools demonstrates the breadth of options available today. From advanced capabilities like high speed signal analysis to cloud-based global team design, these platforms enable productivity and innovation across the PCB workflow. For organizations evaluating PCB design systems, this overview provides a starting point to narrow down your shortlist based on feature needs, budget, and electronic design culture and ecosystem. By matching organizational requirements to tool strengths and deployment models, engineering teams can leverage PCB design automation to achieve product goals and accelerate market success.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the main advantages of an integrated PCB design tool?

A: Integrated tools with unified schematic, layout, library management, and manufacturing capabilities reduce tool switching and streamline workflow. Integrated tools also enable greater synchronization between domains and automation across the design flow.

Q: How important are library and component management capabilities in a PCB design system?

A: Library capabilities are very important. Ready access to comprehensive component libraries speeds design time by eliminating repetitive symbol and footprint creation work. Library lifecycle management also assures designers access the right validated library elements rather than outdated or unapproved footprints.

Q: What training is required to become proficient in a PCB design tool?

A: Most tools can be learned in 40-80 hours of hands-on training. Learning the basic features can happen faster. But mastering advanced productivity tools and workflows takes longer. Formal training is recommended to gain proficiency faster. Some tool providers offer certification programs to document tool expertise.

Q: What are DRCs and why are they important in PCB design?

A: Design rule checks validate a PCB layout adheres to specified clearances, spacing, trace widths, and other constraints. DRCs are critical for ensuring manufacturability, reliability, and performance. DRCs integrated into the tool avoid surprises late in the design process.

Q: How does Revision Control help with PCB design?

A: Revision control systems record incremental changes and provide version history. This supports parallel workflows and tracks design progress. Revisions enable designers to experiment without risk of losing working baselines. Integrated revision control improves design team collaboration.

How to Spot Counterfeit Electronic Components

circuit board electronic components

Introduction

Counterfeit electronic components are a major issue facing the electronics supply chain. Unknowingly using fake or substandard parts can jeopardize product quality, reliability, and safety. Unfortunately, counterfeits have infiltrated authorized distributor channels and even original component manufacturers (OCMs). Combating counterfeits requires diligence across organizations involved in sourcing, procurement, quality control, and production. This article provides guidance on detecting counterfeit electronic components to aid in keeping them out of your supply chain.

How Counterfeits Enter the Supply Chain

To protect against counterfeits, it’s important to understand how they infiltrate the electronics ecosystem. Common paths include:

  • Independent distributors – Unscrupulous brokers re-sell used, recycled, remarked, or outright fake components acquired through various means.
  • Contract manufacturers – Some CM’s cut costs by quietly sourcing from unauthorized channels susceptible to fakes.
  • Online marketplaces – Counterfeiters leverage sites like Alibaba and eBay with little oversight on authenticity.
  • Phony franchises or manufacturers – Imposter operations pose as authorized sources and sell remarketed or fake parts.
  • Recycled materials – Legally recycled e-waste can get unlawfully mixed into new stock.
  • Theft and remarking – Components rejected or scrapped by OCMs get stolen and resold as new.

While motivations and sources vary, the common thread is introducing counterfeit components into supply chains that lack adequate screening processes.

Impacts of Using Fake Components

Xilinx Zynq fpga
Xilinx Zynq fpga

The risks of counterfeit parts include:

  • Product defects – Failure rates may be higher with poor quality or unsuitable components.
  • Safety hazards – Device malfunctions can pose danger to users and the public.
  • Field failures and recalls – Widespread issues upon deployment require expensive corrective actions.
  • Reputation damage – Quality incidents erode customer trust and hurt brand image.
  • Liability – Injury or loss arising from counterfeits can spark litigation.
  • Delays – Discovering fakes during production halts work while sources are reconsidered.

The only sure way to avoid these pitfalls is preventing counterfeits from entering your supply chain in the first place.

How to Detect Potential Counterfeit Parts

Careful inspection, testing, and due diligence is required to reveal signs a component may be counterfeit. Here are key detection practices:

Visual Inspection

Closely examine components for any irregularities compared to the datasheet specifications:

  • Markings – Check for missing, wrong, blurred, or inconsistent labeling
  • Package – Differences in materials, molding, dimensions, weight, etc.
  • Leads – Damage, discoloration, corrosion, or bend/spacing issues
  • Surfaces – Signs of remarking, texturing mismatches, poor plating, etc.

X-Ray Inspection

X-ray images reveal internal structures that may deviate from authentic parts:

  • Die size, shape, location, or bond wires don’t match datasheet
  • Missing layers, components, connections, or defects
  • Signs of old die recrystallization from prior use
  • Incorrect substrate, frame, lid, or materials

Electrical Testing

Parameter measurements outside datasheet specs can indicate counterfeiting:

  • Comparative testing of multiple units shows wide variances
  • Functionality testing yields failures
  • Out of spec values for voltage, current, capacitance, frequency, etc.
  • Abnormal waveforms or transient behaviors

Destructive Analysis

Physically delaminating and examining die, packaging, materials, and construction often exposes overt signs of counterfeiting.

Supply Chain History

  • Trace part numbers back through intermediaries to the OCM
  • Verify certifications for each supply chain intermediary
  • Check for continuity and paperwork throughout the chain of custody
  • Look for any high risk entities in the transaction history

How to Avoid Counterfeit Sources

Making sure you only deal with trusted, authorized sources is central to avoiding counterfeits. Here are best practices for qualifying suppliers:

Only Work with Franchised Distributors

Vetted, franchised distributors authorized by the OCM tend to be much more reliable than independent distributors:

  • Verify distributor authorization with the manufacturer
  • Require contractual assurance parts are sourced only from the OCM or other authorized channel partners
  • Get written warranties parts are new, unused, and authentic

Perform Supplier Audits

Conducting periodic audits provides more assurance of supplier authenticity capabilities:

  • Inspect facilities for proper storage, traceability controls, and testing
  • Interview staff on processes for inspector training, sampling, handling defects, etc.
  • Review policies, certifications, record keeping, and quality management
  • Examine inventory for any suspect parts

Require Supplier Certification

Mandatory supplier certification helps screen out disreputable sources:

  • AS6081 – Anti-counterfeiting standard for electronic parts
  • ISO 9001 – International quality management system standard
  • IATF 16949 – Rigorous standard for automotive suppliers
  • Nadcap – Supplier accreditation for aerospace industry
  • AS9100/AS9120 – Standards addressing counterfeit electronic components

Demand Test Reports

Require suppliers provide detailed test reports from independent labs proving parts meet OEM specifications.

Contractual Obligations

Bind suppliers to contracts requiring:

  • Notification if any indication parts may be counterfeit or at risk
  • Certificates of Conformance with accompanying documentation
  • Indemnification against financial damages from supplying fakes
  • Right to conduct unannounced audits of facilities, processes, and inventory
  • Access to traceability and anti-counterfeit records

Anti-Counterfeit Technologies

Some OCMs are adopting emerging tech like blockchain, smart tags, and DNA marking to track, authenticate, and confirm component provenance throughout the supply chain. Require use of these protections whenever possible.

How to Screen for Counterfeits Internally

Xilinx FPGA distributor
Xilinx FPGA distributor

Your own inspection processes represent the last line of defense before counterfeits enter production. Best practices include:

Sample Destructive Testing

Perform teardowns, chemical analysis, microscopy, and other destructive tests on a sample of high-risk components to look for counterfeit indicators.

X-Ray Screening

X-ray imaging is very effective at revealing many fake components right away before they get any further.

Thorough Inspection

Use a checklist to methodically examine each aspect of components – markings, dimensions, leads, molding, etc.

Parameter Testing

Test key parameters on a sample of units to identify outliers that merit further investigation.

Random Sampling

Apply screening techniques randomly even across low-risk component batches to keep suppliers honest.

Staff Training

Educate staff on detecting discrepancies that may indicate counterfeiting and flag for further review.

Quarantine Suspect Parts

Isolate any potentially counterfeit parts to avoid them inadvertently entering manufacturing.

Report Issues

Alert internal stakeholders and suppliers regarding suspect parts to trigger further containment actions.

With rigorous prevention and detection controls integrated across the supply chain, companies can effectively combat counterfeits and reduce risk.

Extensive Risk Mitigation for High Reliability Applications

For mission critical systems where failure poses major safety risks, an even higher standard of anti-counterfeiting is warranted:

  • Single, certified source – Restrict component models to a single fuzzy ID/fuzzy factory source under bond.
  • Witness manufacturing – Observe components being made firsthand at the certified supplier.
  • Full traceability – Require unbroken chain of custody with certified handlers from foundry to destination.
  • Destructive lot sample testing – 100% destructive lot sample analyses to validate authenticity.
  • Lifecycle monitoring – Track components while in use with blockchain or smart tag monitoring.
  • X-Ray all parts – Screen every component, not just samples.
  • No exceptions – Refuse any parts where full criteria is not met.
  • Ongoing supplier audits – Conduct exhaustive facility, process, certification, and personnel auditing.

For less critical commercial goods, these measures may be prohibitive. But when lives depend on it, it’s worth the extra diligence and cost.

Conclusion

While counterfeit components continue infiltrating electronics supply chains, taking proper precautions can greatly reduce your organization’s risk. By partnering only with certified, authorized sources, inspecting diligently, and integrating robust counterfeit avoidance practices across procurement, logistics, quality control, and production you can safeguard product integrity. With growing threats from fake parts, enacting comprehensive anti-counterfeiting measures is a wise investment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How extensive of an issue are counterfeit electronic components?

Counterfeit electronic components have grown into a massive issue, with some estimates indicating up to 10% of parts procured from independent distributors are fake. This problem has mushroomed as global supply chains have become more complex. The impact of counterfeit parts can undermine product integrity on a large scale once they enter global distribution channels.

Q: What are some warning signs a supplier may not be trustworthy?

Red flags include reluctance to provide requested documentation like certificates of conformance, audit rights, and test reports. Lack of industry certifications, evasive answers, unusual payment terms, prices that seem too good to be true, vague company ownership, and other shady attributes also warrant further scrutiny of a supplier’s authenticity.

Q: Is it safe to use components purchased from online marketplaces like Alibaba and eBay?

Generally it is risky and not advisable to source electronic components through online marketplaces. These platforms lack oversight to ensure authentic, authorized parts. The prevalence of counterfeits from such marketplaces makes it an unreliable sourcing channel for anything beyond hobbyist or experimental use. For production applications, only trusted franchised sources should be used.

Q: Can visual inspection reliably detect all counterfeit parts?

While valuable, visual inspection alone is not sufficient in many cases. High quality counterfeits may superficially look identical to authentic parts. More advanced techniques like x-ray imaging, sample destructive testing, electrical parameter validation, and supply chain auditing is often required to reliably weed out sophisticated fakes. The right combination of inspection methods and supply chain controls is needed.

Q: What liabilities can arise from using counterfeit electronic components?

Knowingly or negligently sourcing and installing counterfeit parts in shipping products can open companies up to significant legal liabilities. Product liability lawsuits, regulatory fines, and breach of warranty costs can occur if counterfeits cause systems to malfunction, fail prematurely, or result in other damages. It is imperative to demonstrate reasonable efforts were taken to prevent infiltration of fakes.

Farewell to Counterfeit Electronic Components

Everything that is made on earth by humans has a specific life that it works, after that, this product starts to decay or degrade in performance and in the end it may totally collapse or become obsolete. The designers of that product either it be mechanical or electrical takes numerous parameters into consideration to enhance the life time of that product. So these types of electronic items those which have completed their time and become obsolete or have become faulty, or out dated or damaged and become non-repairable will be thrown as โ€œscrap itemsโ€. These scrap electronics is what contributes to e-waste. The business of scrap and e-waste is a very big industry or multibillion dollar industry.

YouTube video

There are countless electronic products that are being scrapped on daily basis throughout the world and this scrap or e-waste is being bought and sold at various prices. Mostly the e-waste or scrap is exported from the USA to China and other countries where it is washed in polluted water of river and then put on sideways to dry up. After that it is then forged by numerous ways like sanding, painting and applying false marks to make it look new. Hence we can say that the biggest source of the counterfeit components is the e-waste or scrap electronic market itself. It is the responsibility of the governments to devise a strategy to properly dispose of e-waste and scrap electronics so that it may not be accessible to โ€œcounterfeitersโ€

What is Counterfeit Electronic Components?

Many of us might have gone through some electronics parts to be used in hobby projects. Letโ€™s say a 555 timer IC is used in an A-stable multi-vibrator circuit. Now the circuit is developed on breadboard and all the wire connections are intact. Power supply is good and you just turned ON your circuit and put oscilloscope at the output of 555 timer IC but you did not get the waveform. You then checked the oscilloscope settings and found perfectly fine. Now you start to think why my output is not coming, because you have blind believe in IC that it has no problem. You are constantly looking errors in your connections, breadboard, oscilloscope and other passive components, then after struggling half or one hour you realize that the IC itself is โ€œcounterfeitโ€ or โ€œfakeโ€. So what happened in the process is the complete waste of your time, money and effort. This what counterfeit components do..!

A counterfeit component is the low quality, faulty and underrated component that is disguised as high quality or new component and it does not perform function correctly or malfunction causing problems for end users or buyers.

Why Counterfeit Electronic Components are made..?

Now that we understand what is counterfeit electronic components and from where mostly they emerge. As for the reason why they exist in markets is the simple reason โ€œMoneyโ€. Yes, it has been estimated that this counterfeit electronic components industry is so huge that semiconductor industry alone was hit by a huge loss of around $75 billion each year. This monetary loss to the genuine semiconductor industrial sector is converted as earnings for โ€œcounterfeitersโ€. But it may be noted that Original Component Manufactures (OCM) have their manufacturing facilities in various countries of the world like China, Singapore, Indonesia and Malaysia. For-example the headquarters of a particular OCM may be in USA but its facilities/factories working in China may develop various levels of quality of a particular component, but they do mention about the quality, performance and also gives guarantees and warranties which is not the case in counterfeit electronic components being sold by โ€œcounterfeitersโ€.

Reason Why We should not use Counterfeit Electronic Components:

As mentioned above by the example of simple 555 timer IC, the main reason why you should avoid using counterfeit electronic components is because it will not work as expected, it will malfunction, it will be a waste of time, your energy and money.  This is with aspect of a student or hobbyist working on a final year project or doing experiments for learning so it may not be a big loss. However if you are an ECM (Electronic Contract Manufacturer) and your production facility has ordered 100,000 pieces of 555 timer IC and out of which 1000 counterfeit then this will be a big issue. The losses are multiplied in terms of every aspect like production cost will increase due to counterfeit components themselves, waste of resources used in production line for example if the components are soldered then whole PCB batch may have to be discarded, the labor cost (hourly wages) of that batch run was wasted, other overhead charges and electricity charges are also counted as loss due to only those counterfeit parts.

Moreover, these above mentioned losses are in the case when the faulty PCB batch (due to counterfeit parts) was caught on right time. But if the production facility members could not catch the problem then the resulting faulty or underrated product will be distributed in market thus annoying the customers and degrading the companyโ€™s (ECMโ€™s) reputation. This will cause lower future orders and customers may lose confidence.

The counterfeit electronic components can damage other electronics parts on the PCB thus rendering the PCB unable or very difficult to repair. The counterfeit electronic components if found in sensitive medical instrument in operation theatre or surgical device can make it stop working randomly thus causing serious issues to human life and can be life threatening. A counterfeit electronic component if found in aircraft electronics can raise serious risk of lives of many passengers and pilot thus these losses are irreversible. This is why medical and aerospace components are always high grade i.e. military spec so there is almost no chance of counterfeit components to get through.

Another reason Counterfeit components should not be used is because they can be dangerous to the overall device or system where they are installed or soldered. Because they can malfunction, or can become short circuit leading to sparking or catching fire or totally damaging the end product/device or even injure the person using it. For example a counterfeit Lithium ion battery can swell and exploded thus injuring the mobile phone user.

Types of Counterfeit Electronic Components:

There is a large number of electronic components sellers, distributors, resellers, wholesalers and manufacturers who deal in electronic components. Majority of them are selling genuine parts but many of them are also among those โ€œCounterfeitersโ€. These counterfeit components are also called forged or fraudulent components that exist in almost every electronics market. Talking about the ECM, it is the responsibility of   supply chain and procurement department to contract very carefully with only those distributors or franchises that are authenticated by OCM (Original Component Manufacturers). It is best to buy components directly from OCM but if not possible then always search for genuine authorized dealers from OCM in your respective country. There are many types of counterfeit components you can encounter. Some of them are

1- Low Specification Components Are Disguised as High Specification Component:

This type of counterfeit component is the one in which a poor quality partโ€™s surface is โ€œsand downโ€ to remove the original markings and then reprint the fake part number to resemble the new high quality component which it is not in actual. Then they polish the surface using thin layer of Blacktopping material.  Sometimes they mix small quantity of low spec parts with large quantity of genuine parts so they cannot be easily identified and sell the whole lot with price of high spec/genuine part per piece.

2- Defective Parts:

As the case above shows the low quality or low grade component are sold by tuning their appearance, here in this case the completely defected component is taken and then same procedure above is repeated and made it look like new part and sold at higher prices. You should be aware of these illegitimate practices of counterfeiters as they can strike a serious dent in your business as discussed above in detail.

3- Used Parts sold as New:

In this case, the used parts are polished and appearance is changed and looks shinier than the genuine part. The problem is that they do not tell their customers that this is used component and it is refurbished but they sell them as new and charge cost of new component which is totally illegal.

How to tell the component is Counterfeit.

The most important question is how to determine an electronic component to be counterfeit or genuine. In order to do this, you must be an expert or have some experience with electronic components especially with Integrated Circuits. Some basic tools to examine an electronic component are

1- Microscope with high magnification

2- High Definition camera to take pictures then correlate with genuine and counterfeit parts and

3- A solvent like acetone or a solvent that is a mixture of 3 parts spirit and 1 part alcohol in order to remove any fake coatings/markings on the surface of IC.

4- X-Ray machine to examine the inner workings of the IC

5- Electrical testing setup like DMM, Oscilloscope, Function generator and test circuit from Datasheet or Application note.

The common methods to identify a counterfeit component are

1- Check for misspellings and wrong information on labels.

2- Ensure that part number and date coding on the label match those on the part itself.

3- Verify the part number against the genuine part number as OCM uses and ensure it is correct.

4- You can check out for any blunder mistake like date code of the โ€œfutureโ€ labeled on the IC package.

5- Check out for incorrect logo

6- Confirm that the font used on the suspected counterfeit part matches the font used on genuine part.

7- Verify the country of origin against the lot code number as the two lots with same code number cannot be manufactured in different countries. So for example if the country of origin name printed on suspected counterfeit part is Malaysia and other genuine part shows Philippines and both parts have same lot code number than it confirms the one is counterfeit part.

8- Examine the indents. The number one and strongest way to catch the counterfeit component is to examine the indents. Because counterfeiters have a very difficult time keeping the indents clean and consistent during their refinishing process.

For example, in the picture on the right, these two parts were received in the same lot and have identical part number markings. These are the same ends next to each other and you can see that one has 3 indents and the other has just 2. The shape and size of the indents are also different. One is a rounded cavity and the others are all flattened.

Another example of indent is this shown in the figure. The indents from the manufacturer or OCM are always clean and uniform in each and every part of the lot. However this indent shown has been filled up with blacktopping materials that was used to disguise the surface by hiding the old surface.

One more example shows the clear and obvious difference between the two parts having same part number printed from same lot. As shown in figure below the indent on one is much larger and on other it is nonexistent. This is clear and obvious example of counterfeit electronic component.

How to Avoid Counterfeit Electronic Components:

1- Rigorously Control Purchase Sources

2- Always try to buy directly from OCM

3- If not possible to buy from OCM, then go for OCM authorized dealers, suppliers or franchises

4- Look for any reputable distributor who has good reputation and customer feedback if you could not manage points 2 and 3 above

5- Deploy an inspection team that will examine the incoming parts as per the guides hints discussed

6- If you cannot deploy an inception team due to budget constraints then you can outsource the job to third party Company to avoid this headache and speed up the process.

7- Always try to avoid obsolete components in your designs but if unavoidable always look for trusted partner in component sourcing that will not deceive you.

Conclusion:

There are numerous examples of counterfeit electronic components that are floating in the electronic markets. Countless number of sellers, distributers and shops are dealing in these semiconductor electronic ICs, but it is the responsibility of the procurement division of the ECM (Electronic Contract Manufacturer) to rigorously control purchase source and always try to buy directly from OCM (Original Component Manufacturer) or any authorized dealer or franchise of OCM so that the risk of obtaining forged parts is minimized.

Applications and Types of PCBs for Automotive Industry

Automotive PCB

Introduction

Printed circuit boards (PCB) play a pivotal role in the functioning and performance of automotive electronics. From powertrain systems to ADAS, infotainment and lighting, PCBs can be found enabling various functions. The harsh under-the-hood environment along with increasing electronics complexity impose stringent requirements on automotive PCBs. In this article, we will take a look at key PCB applications in vehicles, critical design considerations and specialized PCB types used in the automotive industry.

PCB Applications in Automotive

Some major application areas using PCB technology in modern vehicles:

Powertrain Control

  • Engine control unit
  • Transmission control module
  • Battery management system
  • Traction inverter & converter

ADAS Systems

  • Camera modules
  • Radar PCBs
  • LiDAR electronics
  • Vision processing units

Infotainment Head-units

  • Navigation system
  • Audio amplifier
  • Telematics gateway
  • Display graphics module

Body Control

  • Lighting/luminaire PCBs
  • Door control module
  • HVAC control
  • Central gateway ECU

Instrument Clusters

  • Odometer
  • Driver information display
  • Telltales and warning lights

Security Modules

  • Immobilizer PCB
  • Central locking ECU
  • Blind spot detection

PCB Design Challenges in Automotive

Automotive Electronics
Automotive Electronics

Designing PCBs for automotive applications brings unique challenges:

High Vibration/Shock Loads

  • Vibration from engine and road noises.
  • Shock from bumps and unequal road surfaces.

Wide Temperature Range

  • Under-the-hood temperature up to 125ยฐC.
  • Cold temperature down to -40ยฐC.

Electromagnetic Interference

  • Switching noise from motors and actuators.
  • RF interference from transmitters.

High Voltages

  • DC bus voltage upto 650V in electric vehicles.
  • Fast transients like load dump.

Mixed Signal Circuits

  • Combination of sensitive analog and noisy digital circuits.

Safety and Reliability Critical

  • Rigorous product validation needed.
  • Adherence to ISO26262 functional safety standard.

Key PCB Design Considerations

To meet the demanding automotive environment, certain design practices are followed:

Component Selection

  • Automotive grade components rated for extended temperature range.
  • Parts qualified based on AEC-Q101 standard testing.

Layout Design

  • Minimum clearance and creepage distance as per ISO 6469-3.
  • Safety critical layout separation and partitioning.

Power Integrity

  • Robust power distribution network design.
  • Protection against voltage transients.
  • Effective grounding.

Signal Integrity

  • Controlled impedance routing for high-speed buses.
  • Effective EMI and noise filtering.

Thermal Management

Vibration Resistance

  • Component bonding, underfill and encapsulation techniques.
  • Board stiffening elements like aluminum baseplate.

Conformal Coating

  • Paraxylene, acrylic, polyurethane or epoxy coating.
  • Protection against dust, moisture, chemicals.

Safety Standards

  • Compliance to ISO 26262 Functional Safety standard.
  • Adherence to MISRA coding guidelines.

Reliability Testing

  • Industry standard validation as per AEC-Q100, AEC-Q101.
  • Accelerated testing – temperature cycling, humidity, HASS etc.

Types of PCBs Used in Automotive

RF Board for for automotive collision avoidance radar
RF Board for for automotive collision avoidance radar

Different types of PCB technologies and constructions are leveraged to meet the demanding automotive application requirements:

Rigid PCBs

  • Conventional FR-4 glass epoxy rigid PCBs.
  • Higher Tg variants like FR-4 High Temp for thermal reliability.
  • Halogen-free and flame retardant materials.
  • Metal core boards for thermal management.

Flexible PCBs

  • Single, double or multilayer flex circuits.
  • Suit applications with space constraints or movement.
  • Polyimide material for flexibility at higher temperatures.

Rigid-Flex PCBs

  • Combination of rigid and flexible sections.
  • Allows three dimensional routing.
  • Used to interconnect multiple PCBs.

Metal Backed PCBs

  • Insulated metal substrate (IMS) or metal core PCBs.
  • Metal baseplate aids heat dissipation and EMI shielding.

High Frequency PCBs

  • RF designs with precise impedance control and absorbers.
  • Low-loss material substrates like PTFE.
  • Synthetic heat sinks for power amplifiers.

New PCB Trends in Automotive

Emerging trends in automotive PCB technologies include:

HDI PCBs

  • High density interconnects to integrate more functionality.
  • More routing layers, microvias and thinner dielectrics.

High Thermal Conductivity Dielectrics

  • Dielectrics with ceramic fillers for improved thermal dissipation.

Low Temperature Co-fired Ceramic (LTCC)

  • Multilayer ceramic PCBs for demanding RF and power modules.

Additive Processes

  • Additive fabrication to produce high aspect ratio fine features.
  • Technologies like aerosol jet printing.

Embedded Passives

  • Passives like resistors and capacitors integrated within the PCB.
  • Saves space and improves electrical performance.

Panel Level Packaging

  • Panel scale manufacturing vs single PCBs.
  • Allows integration of PCB, ICs, passives etc.

Quality and Reliability Testing

  • Higher reliance on automotive industry standards like AEC-Q100/101, IPC-A-610G Automotive Addendum.
  • In-circuit and functional testing.
  • Accelerated life testing.

Conclusion

From engine control units to ADAS cameras, PCBs have become indispensable in modern vehicles due to the electronics revolution. Automotive PCB design requires mastering signal integrity, robust power distribution, thermal management and mechanical reliability while meeting stringent industry standards. As automotive electronics complexity grows exponentially, innovations in PCB materials, high density integration, quality/reliability validation and panel scale manufacturing will be critical to realize future mobility visions.

FAQs

  1. What are some key factors driving increased electronics content in automobiles?

Demand for connectivity, infotainment, electrification, autonomous features is driving rapid growth in automotive electronics content.

  1. What is the typical temperature rating required for under-the-hood automotive PCBs?

Due to high temperature environment, under-the-hood PCBs must withstand temperatures of 105ยฐC to 125ยฐC.

  1. How does ISO26262 relate to automotive PCB design?

It provides an automotive functional safety framework with requirements traceability impacting PCB design validation.

  1. Which construction provides higher thermal conductivity – IMS or MC PCB?

Insulated metal substrate (IMS) has dielectric directly bonded to metal baseplate giving higher thermal conductivity than metal core PCB.

  1. What are some key board level reliability tests done for automotive PCB qualification?

Common reliability tests include temperature cycling, shock/vibration, humidity/bias, HTOL (high temperature operating life) etc.

The industrial sector has seen a tremendous boom in past decade when the demand in automobile exponentially increased due to rapidly growing automation technology. Today the automobile giants like Toyota, Honda, BMW, Ford and Tesla are producing such a high class automobiles and targeting specific consumer class that can buy such a marvelous piece of art of automation engineering. Besides mechanical engineering miracles we all know that brought the revolution in cars and automobile vehicles, the electronics engineering industry has now got involved extensively in automobile industry. Todayโ€™s automobile vehicle is a combination of true art of mechanical and electronics engineering. All of the aesthetics that we see in high class sports car like Lamborghini or Ferrari, or we see power control system in heavy loaded trucks like Caterpillar or Komatsu lifters, cranes etc we see that the control system working behind is based on some sort of Electronic Control System (ECS). And this ECS is founded on Special kind of Automotive PCB.

Automotive PCB Applications and Types

Applications of Automobile PCBs:

Like Caterpillar 797F mining truck has the electronic clutch pressure control, service break sensor, Engine sensor, ARC switch, service break, secondary break control, axle speed sensor circuit, position and steering sensor circuits. There are lots of other examples of general use consumer cars with impressive dashboard,  with LED or LCD display, GPS and radar electronics embedded on dashboard, FM radio, automatic doors and locking systems, electronic relays to control fuel valves/solenoids, timer circuits for engine, Engine Control Unit (ECU) or Engine Control System (ECS) PCB modules, automatic mirror controller, Airbag controller, and front, rear and side LED light control and drive circuits for headlights, back lights and indicator lights respectively, car speed and acceleration sensor and display circuits, Car Battery Management system circuits, wireless key remote door locking system for car safety, air conditioning control etc.

The auto driver system in modern automobile cars is totally PCB based and highly sophisticated electronic circuits are functioning behind the scene. These PCBs are made pre-programmed for sensing the surrounding environment of car to detect obstacle around it in neat vicinity. This is commonly done by IR and Doppler radar system. The auto robot car driving system will take control of car brake, clutch and race and makes decision based on the inputs from surrounding and programming fed in the complicated automotive PCBs.

Although these automobile PCBs are powered by car batteries which is in most cases maintenance free batteries and all the car electronics is operated by this 12VDC battery system. The cabling and wire harness is laid inside the car along with fuses to prevent the electronics from over current or overvoltage surges.

Automotive PCB Applications and Types

Electric Vehicle:

Nowadays, we see in newspaper, electronic media and people talking about future cars that will run totally on batteries and no fuel or diesel will be required for car now. Yes this is true, scientist and engineers have come-up with a new invention in the battery system that these batteries will charge in the matter of few hours and will give backup to your care for many days. This system is just like our smart-phones that once charged in few hours will give back-up 2-3 days. But there are differences in this novel technology because some electric vehicle will give few days of back and mileage while other can gives battery charging power for weeks. Obviously, the technology of E-Vehicles or Electric Vehicle is not possible without Automotive PCBs. Although our discussion in previous section was just to power up the accessory car electronics and engine control while the fuel was still the diesel and oil, while here in this case the car is totally โ€œelectrifiedโ€ completely eliminating the need of fuel or diesel.

Types of Automotive PCBs:

Automotive PCB Applications and Types

From our discussion above it is clear that the automotive PCBs should be something that will give the highest performance in terms of power dissipation, efficient heat transfer, long life cycle and robustness. Commonly if we open up the deck or dashboard of our cars we see a complex electronics and wiring inside with relays, fuses and sockets mounted and connecting various modules with each other. These Electronic components are all mounted on Rigid PCBs that are High Density Interconnect (HDI) PCBs, Heavy copper PCBs to allow high amount of current flow from car battery to accessory electronic, ceramic substrate PCBs to bear against harsh, stringent environment of car surrounding like car moving in deserts, forest, mountainous regions or running in hot sunny weather.

The aluminum based Metal Core PCBs (MCPCBs) are commonly seen in automotive electronics that consist of bright LED lights. These bright LED lights draw high current from battery and in turn gives high luminosity white light. Moreover the small motors hidden inside car body to control the cars fins, windows, side mirrors or any part that is moving, draws good enough current from battery. Hence the need of heavy copper PCB is required to provide least resistance path to the flow of current so as to protect/avoid PCB to melt down due to high temperature / heat generated by high currents.

There are flexible PCBs also found in car electronics front dashboard, connecting large LED, LCD display to the processor board, or connecting various electronic modules each other by flexible PCBs. Flexible PCBs are light weight and can be adjusted/flexed inside the small space available in car deck/dashboard. The combination of rigid and flexible PCBs called Rigid-Flex PCBs are also found in Automotive PCBs.

Rayming PCB Services for Automotive PCBs:

At Rayming PCB Our expertise in manufacturing automotive PCBs is vast. We assure high quality and robust PCB manufacturing services. Our PCBs are ISO 9001-2008 and UL certified, so you know they are reliable, durable that will last long. We are the one-stop shop for all your PCB manufacturing and assembly needs. Our proven reputation among our valued clients shows the quality product we deliver. Please send us the design specifications and details about your Automotive PCB at this email sales@raypcb.com

Future of Automotive and PCB Industry Together:

These two gigantic industries can change the shape of the automation industry. As we witness today that cars have been invented totally depending upon electricity and batteries and completely knocking out the need of fuel pumps. Now in future electric charging stations will charge your car like a smart-phone and your will then drive your car more โ€œEnergy efficientlyโ€ and more environment friendly. Having said that, the electronics PCB manufacturing and assembly industry is the Part and Parcel of automotive industry. It is just the matter of time that world would see these automotive PCBs being used as an integral part of every carโ€™s engine electronics, as carโ€™s accessories electronics and completely replacing mechanical fuel engines with electronic car engines and interface electric motors to drive your car effectively.

How to Design a Backplane PCB?

impedance control pcb

Introduction

A backplane is a high-speed printed circuit board that acts as the backbone of complex electronic systems like telecom, networking and industrial equipment. It provides interconnections between various cards and modules plugged into the system chassis. Designing reliable and optimized backplanes requires careful planning and execution to meet signal integrity, power delivery and mechanical challenges. This article provides a comprehensive guide on backplane PCB design covering architecture, layout considerations, material selection, analysis and validation steps.

Backplane Basics

Some fundamentals about backplane PCBs:

  • Provides interconnects between various PCBs and hardware units like line cards, switch fabric, storage modules etc. mounted on the chassis.
  • Enables high-speed data transfer and communication between modules using parallel bus interfaces like PCIe, Ethernet etc.
  • Contains multiple high-density board-to-board connectors to plug in cards and daughterboards.
  • Requires very careful impedance control and signal integrity design due to multi-GHz signal speeds.
  • Must handle significant power distribution to provide clean power to all modules.
  • Undergoes thermal and mechanical stresses requiring robust mechanical structure.
  • Fabricated using thick multilayer PCBs with 12+ layers typically.

Backplane Architecture

Defining the right backplane architecture is the first step:

Module Interconnect

  • Analyze inter-module data flow and bandwidth requirements.
  • Select suitable interconnect types like Ethernet, PCIe, proprietary buses etc.
  • Determine number of lanes, data rates, signaling levels etc. for each interface.

Connector Selection

  • Choose right angle or vertical mount connectors based on space availability.
  • Determine mounting type – press-fit, soldered, Z-axis elastomer etc.
  • Select connectors suited for target signal speeds and pin counts required.

Slot Planning

  • Define number and spacing of card slots based on modules.
  • Plan spacing for adequate airflow and cooling.

Form Factor and Dimensions

  • Select suitable backplane dimensions and board outline- ATCA, VME64x, cPCI etc.
  • Define positioning of power connectors, modules, card guides etc.

Electrical Design

Hardware Layout
Hardware Layout

The electrical design focuses on power, signal routing and placements:

Power Distribution

  • Design power tree starting from system power inputs to local regulators on each module.
  • Use thick power/ground planes for distribution of various rail voltages.
  • Add numerous decoupling capacitors adjacent to each connector for clean power.

Layer Stackup

  • Use 20+ layer count stackup with multiple signal-reference plane pairs.
  • Maintain same dielectric materials and thickness throughout for impedance control.

Signal Routing

  • Route critical clock and data lines on inner layers adjacent to reference planes.
  • Match trace widths and clearances to achieve target impedance.
  • Enable impedance control on design software to assist routing.

Component Placement

  • Place bypass capacitors, termination resistors etc. close to connectors.
  • Position on-board controllers, drivers and other active devices optimally.

EMI Control

  • Use shielding gaskets around connectors and board periphery.
  • Include Board-EMI filters for power and signal interfaces.

Mechanical Design

The mechanical design of backplane is also critical:

Card Guides and Support

  • Include guides and slots for precise card insertion and retention.
  • Add stiffeners to prevent board flexing under card weight.

Connector Mounting

  • Use press-fit or soldered connectors to withstand mating cycles.
  • Apply appropriate footprint for selected connector.
  • Add stiff backing supports for connectors to avoid flexing during insertion/removal.

Thermal Management

  • Ensure sufficient air flow channels for cooling.
  • Use thermally conductive dielectric materials.
  • Add thermal pads/vias underneath hot devices.

Vibration and Shock

  • Design robust mounting and retention for mechanical durability.
  • Perform vibration/shock analysis using FEA.

Analysis and Validation

Backplanes require extensive validation due to high complexity:

Signal Integrity Simulations

  • Perform IBIS simulations to evaluate eye diagrams, timing, jitter etc.
  • Analyze signal quality for links like PCIe, Ethernet.

Power Integrity Analysis

  • Execute power integrity analysis focused on AC and transient behavior.
  • Verify power supply regulation, ripple, droop/overshoot are within limits.

Thermal Analysis

  • Carry out thermal modeling using computational fluid dynamics software.
  • Ensure temperature rise is acceptable for devices and dielectric materials.

Prototyping

  • Build multiple prototypes for design validation and testing.
  • Use controlled impedance sockets, loads, probes etc. for evaluation.

Conclusion

Shengyi WLM1 PCB

Designing reliable and high-performance backplane PCBs requires strong foundation in signal integrity, power distribution, electromagnetic compatibility and mechanical engineering. A structured approach covering architectural planning, electrical and mechanical design, prototyping, analysis and testing is key to develop complex backplanes successfully on tight schedules. With growth in data networks and modular systems, role of backplane continues to increase for interconnecting modern electronics systems.

FAQs

  1. What are some examples of standard backplane form factors?

Some common form factors are CompactPCI, VMEbus, FASTBUS, Raceway, ATCA, VXS etc.

  1. How is clock distributed in large backplane designs?

Clocks are distributed through balanced clock trees using traces, striplines and clock buffers for skews control and to minimize distortions.

  1. What are some typical high-speed interfaces used in backplane?

PCI Express, 10Gb Ethernet, Infiniband, RapidIO, StarFabric, Serial ATA are commonly used backplane interfaces.

  1. What type of connectors are suited for backplane applications?

High-density, high-speed board-to-board connectors like mezzanine, HDI and FCBGA types are commonly used on backplanes.

  1. Why are backdrilled vias used extensively in backplane PCBs?

Backdrilling reduces via stubs allowing higher data rates and improved signal integrity for differential traces routed through vias.

Backplane PCBs: Introduction

Generally a Backplane PCB is a collection of multipleconnectors placed and connected on one PCB. By nature its responsibility is to carry signals like a cable from one connector to other but enough good health such as single0ended, differential paired signals, and power supply rails and return paths. The PCBs with semiconductor ICs are directly press-fit over a backplane PCB. These insertable cards or PCBs are called daughter cards. It makes the pins of sourceconnectors to be connected exactly on the required pinsof destination connectors.

YouTube video

A backplane PCB,in complexity is somehow similar to a motherboard PCB in respect of PCB design parameters but it has manydifferences in manufacturing process and functionality. A motherboard, well known to be densely routed signals board with high pin cunt semiconductor ICs. On the other enda backplane is considered an enough connectivity board on the โ€œbackโ€ of boards. But a backplane PCB is much more than a connectivity board especially for high datarate communication systems. A backplane PCB transports allelectrical connectivity of signals and powersin between daughter boards.It also holds and supports daughter cards over it which can be press-fit or extract. 

It increases throughput of system on the cost of increased design and manufacturing effort. Although, the early times backplanes do have wire-wrapped connectorsand sockets but data speed in newer systems has realized to utilize advance PCBs materials and manufacturing skills for backplane PCBs. It originated further PCB manufacturing constraints alongwith the existing ones. PC (Printed Circuit) based Backplanes are preferred over wire-wrapped backplanes due to their increased reliability and data carriage capability.In common practice Backplanes donโ€™tcomprises of semiconductor chips over them. However, they have small electronic components like resistors, capacitors, filters and chassis ground circuitry over them.

Backplane Manufacturing Difficulties:

The Backplane PCBs have enhanced data throughput, signal travelling quality, ease of assembly and production but still it increased challenges for PCB manufacturers.

The Backplane PCB thickness increases because it consists of several high speed controlled impedance transmission lines, supply rail planes ad return paths.Transmission of high frequency data over longer traces requires wide signals traces to reduce signal attenuations.  It needs thicker dielectric capable to maintain impedance and keep the signal absorption lowest. Increasing trace width decreases signal density in a layer in per unit area of PCB. On the other hand increasing dielectric thickness increases overall PCB thickness.

Insertion of more signal layers added to power planes and return planes increases layer count that finally approaches to 20 or even more.It becomes challenging to maintain standard thickness of PCB for a manufacturer with given materials and impedance matching parameters.

High speed fine PCB drilling for vias and connectors in backplanes works well till a thickness of 5 to 6mm. However, larger drill diameters are required for thicker PCBs. Higher drill aspect ratios such as 8:1 constraints manufacturer to volumetric production so thicker PCBs require multiple drill passes for a single via.

It is a common practice to through daughter cared input power supplies by backplanes for examples ยฑ5V, ยฑ12V and ยฑ24V DC. Many a times each power rail needs a separate return path plane to reduce PCB commotion. In such a way it may need upto 12-layers for power supplies.Framework computers having high current power supplies which produce IR losses over the planes copper. Thatneedsheat sinks or heat radiator fans for temperature compensation. Their leading layers need thicker copper compared to other internal layers.With higher layer count PCB layer registration, via alignment, pad-hole alignment and pressing a thicker PCB also becomes difficult.

Overall a high-speed backplane PCB increases entire manufacturing process through routing complexity, etching, layer registration, thickness, weight, material selection, and cost and production process.

  • PCB Pressing

In thicker backplanes manufacturing drilling becomes more complicated. A lengthy drill hole requires multiple times drilling the hole. It decreases drilling accuracy ad PCB yield percentage. It degrades high frequency performance.

  • High density etching

In a backplane PCB due to high count of connectors so their mounting holes and pads use significant part of PCB real-estate. The PCB designers strive to increase signal routing density maintaining impedance, trace length, instead of increasing number of layers. The increased signals density increases etching complexity. It pushes the trace, via-hole, pad-hole, annular ring geometries to the fabrication tolerance limits.

  • Impedance matching

With high speed data transmissions in the backplane PCBs impedance matched PCB fabrication becomes a challenge.Data transmission in GB per second range is generally not recommended over general FR-4 materials. The dielectric constant and dissipation factor dictate the material selection for backplane PCBs. This creates a challenge for PCB manufacturer to provide PCBs on demanded materials. The transmission line impedance, via impedance and connector pad to pin impedance also becomes a challenge. A new material type needs PCB manufacturing process to be slightly amendedat manufacturer facility.

  • Via back-drilling

As unused copper piece in PCB can act as stub in high frequency signals.The similar stub-effect may occur due to unused via barrel copper and annular ring. For this purpose PCB manufacturers are pushed to back-drill PCB. It requiresremoving the redundant via barrel from a thru-hole via in a PCB.  The manufacturer removes thatvia copper after PCB fabrication is complete byre-drilling the target holes with a different drill size, leaving a certain length after last layer connection. It slows the production and causes inaccuracies in PCBs.

  • Connectors Alignment

A high speed backplane has good impedance matched connectors over it.  In general a backplane has around 50 impedance controlled differential pairs per square inch. So the total differential pair length approaches to 500 pairs in a plane.The high density SMD and through-hole connectors allow smaller PCB size but they need many blind press-fit insertion and extraction of daughter cards from it. It harmsdurability of PCB. The manufacturerconstraint arises to maintain a hole-locations and geometry of connectors as well as maintaining the signal integrity throughout the PCB.

  • Layer registration

Layer registration in high speed high density PCBs causes low accuracy during copper etching, lamination, drilling and dimensional stability. The signal integrity and PCB yield at smaller sizes becomes more challenging for manufacturer.

  • Aspect Ratio

Aspect ratio is the ratio of drill size to PCB thickness. Dense signals routing,higher copper layers count, and high vias and connector through-holes count in a backplane makes itsaspect ratio high that leads manufacturingdifficulties.PCB design engineers strive to maintain an acceptable ratio figure effective for PCB assembly china and durability. Manufacturers are pushedto manufacture PCBs with 10:1 aspect ratio. However, 6:1 aspect ratio is a common number.

Other common problems which are related to backplane PCBs manufacturing of backplane PCBs are CAF (copper anodic filament), impractical stackups (such as odd-numbered layers PCB design), thickness control of multilayer PCB and high-pressure compression, incomplete manufacturing information, incorrect blind and buried vias placement, improper layer-pairs, environmental impacts on PCB core and pre-preg materials, stringentrequirementsforced by international body regulations.

What is Package on Package (POP) Assembly ?

package on package assembly

Introduction

Package on Package (POP) is an integrated circuit packaging technique used in electronics manufacturing where packaged semiconductor devices are stacked vertically using solder balls. This enables higher component density and improves electrical performance for advanced PCB designs. In this article, we will explore the fundamentals of POP technology, its assembly process, advantages, limitations, applications and future trends.

Overview of POP

POP involves integrating two or more completely packaged devices into a single composite component unit by stacking them vertically. Some key points:

  • Each device is separately packaged first before POP assembly.
  • Devices are interconnected using solder balls or bumps.
  • The bottom device is called the โ€˜base packageโ€™.
  • The top stacked package is called the โ€˜top packageโ€™.
  • Interposer may be used between packages for re-routing.
  • Entire POP assembly is treated as a single packaged component.
  • Also referred to as package-on-package (PoP) or package-over-package.

POP configuration showing stacked packages interconnected by solder balls.

Why POP is Used?

Some key benefits driving the adoption of POP technology:

  • Allows vertical stacking of ICs for increased component density on PCB.
  • Enables integrating disparate technologies like memory, processors, sensors etc.
  • Improves electrical performance through double-sided interconnections.
  • Provides flexibility for modular designs by stacking known good packaged devices.
  • Simplifies PCB routing by reducing number of components required on board.
  • Allows customized configurations suited for target application.
  • Reduces the overall footprint and height compared to side-by-side placement.

POP Components

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECBTjZPoki8&t=32s

POP assembly combines two main types of packaged components:

1. Base Package

  • Typically contains high pin count device like application processor.
  • Provides mechanical support for POP structure.
  • Made with standard packages like FBGA, PBGA, LGA etc.
  • Contains high density of solder balls or bumps on top side.

2. Top Package

  • Usually a memory device like DRAM, flash etc.
  • Comes in packages like TSOP, CSP or wafer-level CSP (WLCSP).
  • Has solder balls only on bottom side.
  • Smaller in size than base package.

Interposer

  • Optional substrate placed between base and top package.
  • Facilitates re-routing of I/O connections.
  • Used to optimize pad layout or enable high density ball grid array (BGA).

POP Manufacturing Process

POP assembly involves the following key manufacturing stages:

1. Sourcing Packaged Components

  • Obtain fully packaged and tested base and top devices.
  • Components must be compatible for stacking and interconnections.

2. Applying Solder Paste

  • Dispense solder paste on base package substrates using stencil.
  • For some assemblies, paste may also be applied on top package.

3. Placing Base Package

  • Mount base package on PCB using standard SMT process.
  • May involve reflow soldering to secure base package.

4. Attaching Top Package

  • Position top package accurately over base package.
  • Orient top package solder balls with base package pads.

5. POP Reflow

  • Reflow solder entire POP assembly to form solder joints.
  • Special oven profiles are used to manage thermal stresses.

6. Underfill Dispensing

  • Wick underfill material via capillary action to fill gap between packages.
  • Underfill provides mechanical stability and prevents stress on joints.

7. Conformal Coating

  • Apply protective encapsulating material over entire assembly.
  • Improves reliability and environmental resistance.

This completes the POP manufacturing process. The components are then put through inspection, programming, testing etc. based on specific product requirements.

POP Design Considerations

Some POP design factors to consider during PCB layout and assembly process planning:

Package Selection

  • Height of stacked packages to meet overall height constraints.
  • Compatible ball pitch, materials and CTE between packages.
  • Solder ball alloy suited to reflow process.
  • Underfill fill requirements based on gap between packages.

Electrical Design

  • Electrical connectivity through solder balls between packages.
  • Minimal stubs lengths for signal routing.
  • Matched impedances for high speed signals.
  • Power, ground and thermal management.

PCB Land Pattern Design

  • Pad shape and size to suit BGA packages.
  • Sufficient clearance between pads and surrounding tracks/vias.
  • Non-solder mask defined pads.

Solder Paste Stencil Design

  • Stencil thickness, aperture size, shape for optimum paste release.
  • Step down thickness in stencil for base package pads.

Process Considerations

  • Compatible reflow profile to solder both packages.
  • Underfill dispensing process window.
  • Balanced placement to minimize warpage.

Advantages of POP

The major benefits provided by Package on Package technology are:

Increased Density

  • Stacking components vertically conserves PCB area.
  • Reduces length of interconnects between packages.

Enhanced Electrical Performance

  • Double-sided interconnects minimize parasitic inductances.
  • Wider power/ground connections improve current delivery.

Lower Height Profile

  • POP provides about 60% height reduction compared to side-by-side placement.
  • Lower profile critical for thin and compact product designs.

Design Flexibility

  • Allows integration of disparate package types.
  • Custom configurations possible by mixing components.

Improved Manufacturability

Cost Savings

  • Eliminates SiP substrate, interconnect layers.
  • Shared reflow process reduces costs.

Disadvantages and Limitations

Some drawbacks and challenges of using POP approach:

Thermo-mechanical Stresses

  • CTE mismatch between packages induces stresses during thermal cycling.
  • Can affect long term reliability of solder joints.

Narrow Process Window

  • Reflow profile optimization is critical for good joint formation.
  • Underfill voiding can occur due to improper dispense process.

Warpage Control

  • Unbalanced stacking leads to significant warpage.
  • Requires symmetrical design and placement during assembly.

Design Constraints

  • Restricts pin assignments, placement and routing on PCB.
  • Requires extensive modeling and analysis.

Inspectability

  • X-ray inspection capability needed to detect defects under top package.
  • Fault isolation challenging in stacked configuration.

POP Applications

Some common application areas where POP technology provides benefits:

Smartphones

  • Memory+processor stacking enables powerful smartphones.
  • Allows integrating memory, power management, RF and sensors.

Wearable Devices

  • Miniaturization for compact wearable product form factors.
  • Lightweight flexible POP solutions ideal for wearables.

Internet of Things (IoT)

  • Small footprint and height critical for many IoT devices.
  • Custom stacking combinations possible for specific devices.

High Density Interconnects

  • Doubled interconnections density compared to peripheral arrays.
  • Well suited for processors requiring high bandwidth memory.

Automotive Electronics

  • Rugged POP packages able to withstand temperature cycling.
  • Suitable for engine control units and in-vehicle infotainment.

The Future of POP

Some emerging trends and developments in POP packaging technology:

  • Hybrid POP configurations integrating passives, sensors along with active ICs using fan-out wafer level packaging.
  • Development of ultra-thin wafer level CSPs as top package for slimmer POP.
  • Utilization of 2.5D and 3D silicon interposers with fine-pitch interconnects.
  • Adoption of through mold vias (TMV) for signal and power delivery through package substrate.
  • Flip-chip underfill process improvements to enable ultra-fine pitch POP scaling.
  • Novel conductive adhesives like anisotropic conductive films (ACF) as interconnect material.
  • Wafer-on-Wafer (WoW) integration for direct device-to-device fine pitch interconnections.
  • Applications in high performance computing and networking equipment.

Conclusion

Package-on-Package represents an exciting packaging innovation that enables continued miniaturization and performance scaling of electronic systems through vertical stacking. With its advantages in density, electrical performance and design flexibility, POP will continue to find increased applicability in space-constrained mobile devices, wearables, IoT as well as high performance designs. Ongoing research and developments are focused on pushing the limits further in terms of interconnect density, stack height, thermal management and manufacturability. As semiconductor integration advances, POP promises to provide an ideal platform for heterogeneous integration of multiple dies and components.

FAQs

  1. How is POP different from package in package (PiP) approach?

In POP, electronic packages are stacked one over the other. In PiP, one package is placed inside another larger package before interconnecting.

  1. What interconnect materials can be used for POP assembly?

Besides solder balls, conductive adhesives like anisotropic conductive films (ACF) and anisotropic conductive pastes (ACP) are also suitable POP interconnects.

  1. Does POP eliminate the need for SiP and multichip modules?

POP provides an alternative by directly stacking known good pre-packaged components. However, SiP and MCM are still used when custom or incompatible devices need to be integrated.

  1. What causes warpage in POP assembly and how is it controlled?

Unbalanced thermal expansion between differently sized top and bottom packages induces warpage. Careful package selection, symmetrical placement and substrate stiffening help reduce warpage.

  1. How does thermal management differ for POP compared to conventional PCB assembly?

Concentrated heat density requires effective heat spreading to packages. Thermal vias, large ground pads and heat slugs are commonly used techniques.

How to Export Gerber Files from Altium

Altium PCB design process

1. Altium Gerber Files

RS-274-X Gerber file format is a defacto data sharing standard for PCB manufacturing. This is basically a printer or plotter language which is used for PCB CAM (Computer Aided Manufacturing) data generation.  Almost everyone who uses Altium Designer software for PCB design, either hobbyist or commercial designer, may have used this feature. It is actually a 2D ASCII file format.

Gerber file format is evolved from applications where it is used to re-create images or graphics i.e., printers and plotters industry. In the same way it is used  in electronics hardware industry to print PCB tracks, vias, pads, text, holes, clearances and all information which is contained in a *.PcbDoc design file. The Altium Designer software tool has a feature to create and gerbtool option to verify data as well.

Like other softwares outputs the Altium Designer gerber file can be divided into four subparts:

  • Configuration Parameters
  • Aperture Definitions
  • Drawing Commands
  • X/Y Coordinates

Each file extension denotes a specific layer such as:

Top Layer => *.gtl

Bottom Layer => *.gbl

Keepout Layer => *.gko

TopOverlay Layer => *.gto

BottomOverlay Layer => *.gbo etc.

2. Generating Gerbers in Altium Designer

YouTube video

Add layer stackup to any of the mechanical or other suitable layer.

Add other information like manufacturing notes, dimensions, cutouts etc., before generating gerber files.

In Altium Designer it is very easy to setup Gerber Files creation setup. It is done by two ways:

Generate through File>Fabrication Outputs> Gerber Files

It opens Gerber Setup dialogue box.

In Gerber setup dialogue box Set file producing unit system.

In layers pane add layers to be re-produced in gerber format.

In drill drawing pane click plot all used layer pairs on both of the boxes.

Set apertures box.

Set advanced parameters in advanced pane or otherwise keep default settings.

Click ok , it generates the gerber outputs in the project folder.

On same method NC drill files are created i.e.,   File>Fabrication Outputs> NC Drill Files and then adopt the same steps as above.

Or in other way it can be generated by following steps:

Output Job File to project > Fabrication Outputs> Gerber Files and then set path for files.

Double click โ€œGerber Filesโ€ it will open Gerber setup. Use the same steps as above and click ok.

Enable output generate option and set target folder location.

Clock Run or double click over generates content. The gerber file outputs will be generated.

Figure 1 Sample PCB Design file

Figure 1: Sample PCB Design file

In figure 1 different layers names are shown in their respective layer. The same layers can be viewed in the final view Figure 5 as Gerber output generated.

Figure 2 Gerbers Settings Dialogue Box

Figure 2: Gerbers Settings Dialogue Box

Figure 3 Gerber Setup Dialogue Box opens

Figure 3: Gerber Setup Dialogue Box opens

Figure 4 Gerber Files generated and viewed in CAMTastic Bottom Layer view

Figure 4: Gerber Files generated and viewed in CAMTastic Bottom Layer view

Figure 5 CamTastic complete PCB view

Figure 5: CamTastic complete PCB view

3. What is Needed by Manufacturer

In a gerber file following layers and information should be added:

  1. 1- Enable all signal layers which have been used for routing in PCB design or those which have electrical signals routing should be enabled to re-produce in gerber format.
  2. 2- Enable all plane layers which are solid copper and distribute power to the circuit on PCB. These are printed as negative image of layer.
  3. 3- Enable Keepout layer, it is usually electrical boundary of the board. The keepout can also be asked to manufacturer for cutting boundary.
  4. 4- Enable required mechanical layers in gerber setup.  A mechanical layer does not have any electrical information like in signal layer or plane layers. However, they can have some information about mechanical parameter like PCB cutting or, 3D PCB footprints information, assembly and fixing in enclosures etc.
  5. 5- Enable Top Overlay and Bottom Overlays which have information of components designators and PCB name, number, nomenclature debug information and test signal details etc.
  6. 6- Dimensional Information: PCB Dimensions information should be added on top overlay or mechanical or keepout layer of PCB design file before generating gerber files.
  7. 7- Layer PCB stackup: Before generating gerber files add layer stackup information in any enabled mechanical layers so that manufacturer can use information about PCB material such as base material thickness, pre-preg thickness type etc.
  8. 8- Preferably produce time and date stamped Gerber files so that they would be back traced for any query.
  9. 9- Recheck and verify the file types using any gerber viewer software tool.
  10. 10-If found accurate and forward to the manufacturer.
Figure 6 Gerber files enable and disable and extensions

Figure 6: Gerber files enable and disable and extensions

Figure 6 shows the gerber files produced by Altium Designer software, produced time, type of layer etc.

4. Summary:

Gerber format is RS-274-X 2D ASCII file format. The gerber file format is a defacto standard of interface between a PCB Design engineer and manufacturer. It includes all conductive, mechanical, text and keepout layers information of a PCB design alongwith necessary notes for manufacturing.

The Altium Designer software produces RS-274-X format Gerber files by different methods.  The latest software and updates about files generation are available on Altium ยฎ. In this tutorial a complete yet comprehensive guide has been provide.

Introduction

Gerber files are the standard format used to transfer PCB design data to fabrication and assembly units. Altium Designer has robust capabilities to generate industry-standard Gerber files needed for board manufacturing. This article provides a detailed guide on the process of exporting Gerber files from an Altium PCB project, with additional tips for file settings and customization.

Gerber File Basics

Gerber files represent PCB layout data in a vector graphics format that can be interpreted by fabrication machines. Here are some key facts about Gerber files:

  • Developed by Gerber Systems in the 1960s, hence the name.
  • Provide image of PCB layers like copper, solder mask, silkscreen, drill files etc.
  • Use RS-274X file format with .gbr extension.
  • Contain vector-based information to image PCB layers.
  • Used for photoplotting fabrication layers on film or directly on boards.
  • Required by PCB manufacturer along with drill files for board fabrication.

Output Job File Settings

Before exporting Gerber files, the key output job settings in Altium must be configured. This is done through the OutJob editor by going to File > Fabrication Outputs > OutJob Editor.

The important parameters are:

ParameterDescription
Output LocationFolder path to save Gerber files
Layer Stack RegionsDefines coverlay and multilayer regions
Layer SpecsSpecifies layers included in outputs
File NamingSets filename prefixes and suffixes
FormatGerber RS-274X, ODB++ etc.
SettingsVarious options like coordinates, zero suppression etc.

The most critical settings are layer stack and layer specifications which determine the actual layers output.

Generating Gerber Files

Once the OutJob is defined, we are ready to export the Gerber files. This involves simply running the output job to generate all the required layers.

The steps are:

  1. Open the PCB project in Altium and go to File > Fabrication Outputs > Generate Gerbers.
  2. Select the OutJob in the Gerber Job Editor window.
  3. Click on Validate outputs – this checks for any errors or missing data.
  4. If validation passes, click on Generate to run the job and output Gerber files.
  5. The Gerber files can be found in the specified output folder location.
  6. By default, a .PDF and .ZIP archive of the files is also generated.

For quick one-click Gerber generation, the OutJob can be added to the Project menu for the PCB. This automates opening the job editor and executing the output process.

Layer Stack Settings

The layer stack regions defined in the OutJob determine which layers are combined to generate the final Gerber files.

For a typical PCB, the layer stacks are:

Layer StackPurpose
Top LayerImages top copper layer
Bottom LayerImages bottom copper layer
Internal LayersImages inner signal layers
Drill DrawingFor NC drill files
Multi-LayerCombines inner and outer layers
Top SolderSolder mask on top side
Bottom SolderSolder mask on bottom side
Top PasteSolder paste layer for top side
Bottom PasteSolder paste layer for bottom side
Top OverlaySilkscreen and other markings on top side
Bottom OverlaySilkscreen and markings on bottom side

Using these layer stacks, all required Gerber files can be generated. Additional stack-ups can also be defined.

Layer Specifications

Layer specifications determine which layers actually get included in a layer stack while generating outputs.

Typical layer inclusions for standard PCB file outputs:

Layer StackLayers Included
Top LayerTop Layer + Multi-Layer
Bottom LayerBottom Layer + Multi-Layer
Internal LayersInner Layers + Multi-Layer
Top SolderTop Solder + Coverlay Top
Bottom SolderBottom Solder + Coverlay Bottom
Top OverlayTop Overlay + Coverlay Top
Bottom OverlayBottom Overlay + Coverlay Bottom

The multi-layer and coverlay combinations merge the signals and plane layers appropriately. Additional specifications like keep-outs can also be added.

File Naming Conventions

Consistent file naming allows easy identification of Gerber files. Recommended naming conventions:

  • File Prefix โ€“ Use project name or PCB code
  • Layer identifier โ€“ TL for Top Layer, TS for Top Solder etc.
  • File Suffix โ€“ Can include version number, date etc.

For example: ProjectABC_TL_Rev1.gbr

This provides a unique ID for each layer file. Similar naming can be applied to drill files.

Important Plot Layers

Some of the key Gerber layers required for fabrication are:

  • Top and Bottom Copper Layers โ€“ Carry signals and traces
  • Internal Plane Layers โ€“ Power, ground and routing layers
  • Top and Bottom Solder Mask โ€“ Defines solderable areas
  • Top and Bottom Silkscreen โ€“ Component markings and legends
  • Board Outline โ€“ Dimensions of finished board
  • Drill Drawing โ€“ For NC drill machine
  • Drill Data โ€“ Size and location of drilled holes

Additional Outputs

Besides standard Gerber layers, additional outputs like the following can also be generated:

  • Copper thickness table โ€“ Specifies finished copper thickness for each layer
  • Netlist file โ€“ Connectivity information for test and analysis
  • Assembly drawings โ€“ Help guide component placement
  • PCB 3D model โ€“ For design visualization
  • Fabrication and Assembly drawings โ€“ Includes callouts, notes, etc.
  • Impedance information โ€“ For controlled impedance designs
  • Stackup details โ€“ Layer materials, properties and sequence

File Validation

Before sending to PCB fabrication, the Gerber files must be thoroughly validated using the following checks:

  • Visual examination โ€“ Open files in Gerber viewer to check if layers contain the expected images.
  • Preflight tests โ€“ Use preflight tools to verify file format, aperture settings etc.
  • CAM tool checks โ€“ Use CAM software to check file opening, merging and editing.
  • Test photoplots โ€“ Get film photoplots made from files to validate image accuracy.
  • Compare netlist โ€“ Use netlist file to check all connections in design are properly imaged.
  • Design rule check โ€“ Ensure critical clearances are maintained in generated images.

File Optimization

Gerber file optimization involves tweaking settings to get smaller files while retaining image quality. Main techniques include:

  • Selecting optimal resolution and image settings.
  • Using zero suppression to reduce file size.
  • Applying data compression while exporting files.
  • Removing duplicate drawing data and unused apertures.
  • Merging layers where possible to reduce file count.

Proper optimization ensures faster file transfers and processing while minimizing storage requirements.

Conclusion

Comprehensive Gerber file generation tools within Altium allow creating all fabrication data needed to manufacture a PCB easily and efficiently. Configuring suitable OutJobs, layer stacks and file settings produces industry-standard outputs that can be directly sent for board fabrication. Validation checks must be performed diligently before file release to avoid errors reaching manufacturing stage. Overall, mastery over the Gerber generation process is crucial to harness the full power of Altium and seamlessly progress from design to fabrication.

FAQs

  1. What are some common problems observed in Gerber files?

Missing copper, malformed apertures, incorrect filenames and layers in wrong files are common Gerber issues. Preflight tools help catch such errors.

  1. How to check if a specific layer is getting correctly output in Gerbers?

Open that Gerber file in viewer and check if key shapes or test structures added to the layer are present in output image.

  1. Why zipping is recommended for Gerber file transfer?

Zipped files occupy less storage space. Zipping also reduces chances of file corruption during internet transfer using protocols like FTP.

  1. What is the difference between PCB fabrication drawing and assembly drawing?

Fabrication drawing guides board manufacture while assembly drawing is used for component placement, annotations during PCB assembly.

  1. How can gaps be avoided between copper layers and planes in Gerber data?

Enable the Remove islands option in Layer Stack Regions. Use proper Positive and Negative layers to define extents.

How to clean manually stencil for SMT assembly

LASER STENCIL MANUFACTURER

Introduction

Stencils are used in surface mount technology (SMT) printed circuit board assembly to apply solder paste pattern on the PCB pads accurately and consistently. Cleaning the stencils regularly is crucial to maintain print quality and avoid defects. While automatic stencil cleaners are commonly used in production, manual cleaning is preferred in case of lower volume or prototype PCB assembly. This article provides a detailed procedure on how to effectively clean stencils manually.

Need for Stencil Cleaning

Some key reasons why regular stencil cleaning is required:

  • Residual solder paste on stencil apertures can cause insufficient or inaccurate solder deposit. This leads to poor prints and missing joints.
  • Paste residues also result in solder balls and mid-chip solder beads affecting assembly yield.
  • Dust, flux and other contaminants on stencil lower print quality and solder paste release.
  • Clogged apertures due to dried paste can alter print definition and stencil life.
  • Insufficient cleaning increases number of misprinted boards.

Thus, stencil cleaning is vital to avoid print defects and maintain process stability in SMT assembly.

Cleaning Frequency

YouTube video

The frequency of stencil cleaning depends on factors like:

  • Volume of PCBs produced per day
  • Size and complexity of solder paste deposits
  • Type of solder paste – some are more sticky and prone to smearing
  • Environmental conditions like humidity and temperature

Typical cleaning frequencies for manual stencil cleaning process:

PCB VolumeCleaning Frequency
1-5 boards per dayAfter each print
5-10 boards per dayAfter every 2-3 prints
>10 boards per dayAfter every 5-10 prints

More frequent cleaning is needed at start to check process and adjust cleaning procedure. The frequency can then be optimized based on print defects.

Materials Required

Following materials are required for manually cleaning the stencils:

  • Cleaning solvents (isopropyl alcohol, acetone etc.)
  • Non-abrasive wipes and swabs
  • Metal squeegee/scrapers
  • Plastic spreader/squeegee
  • Lint-free gloves
  • Set of metal brushes and foam swabs
  • Adhesive tape rolls
  • ESD mat for stencil
  • Protective eyewear

Solvents and wipes should be cleanroom grade. Foam swabs and brushes must be made of non-metallic materials to avoid damage.

Step-by-Step Cleaning Procedure

The detailed manual stencil cleaning process is as follows:

Step 1: Visual Inspection

  • Visually inspect underside of the stencil for dried solder paste, debris and other contamination.
  • Check for paste residues in apertures and open areas of stencil surface.
  • Take note of heavily soiled areas for concentrated cleaning.

Step 2: Preparation

  • Clean hands with solvent or wear lint-free gloves to avoid fingerprints.
  • Place stencil securely on an ESD mat kept on a flat surface.
  • Prepare required cleaning solvents, swabs, wipes etc. Keep different wiping materials for top and bottom side.

Step 3: Loosening Dry Paste

  • Use adhesive tape to remove large chunks of dried paste. Discard after 1-2 uses.
  • Gently roll non-abrasive swabs across underside to loosen paste residues. Apply solvent using swab to assist.

Step 4: Cleaning Apertures

  • Dip soft brass brush in solvent and gently brush inside apertures and around edges to remove clogging.
  • Swipe foam swabs soaked in solvent through apertures to extract remaining paste.

Step 5: Bottom Side Cleaning

  • Saturate cleaning wipe with solvent and wipe the stencil underside in single strokes.
  • Wrap wipe around squeegee and scrape to remove paste buildup on bottom side.
  • Replace wipes as soon as they appear soiled. Change solvent when saturated with paste.

Step 6: Top Side Cleaning

  • Moisten foam swab in solvent and softly rub in direction of stencil tension to clean top side.
  • Use adhesive tape strips to remove paste residues from top surface.

Step 7: Final Cleaning

  • Wipe entire stencil bottom side edge to edge with solvent and wipe in single pass.
  • Similarly, clean stencil top side thoroughly with swab and solvent.
  • Use lens cleaning tissue for final wipe down. Ensure no material is left on squeegee/wiper side.

Step 8: Drying

  • Allow stencil to air dry completely before further use. Drying time depends on solvent used.
  • Alternatively, blow dry with clean compressed air to speed up drying.

Step 9: Inspection

  • Visually examine stencil under bright lights for any remaining paste or contamination.
  • Recheck problem areas and apertures closely to ensure thoroughly clean.
  • Swab test – rub swab across stencil and check if any paste residue shows up on swab.

This completes the stencil cleaning process. Carry out further print trials to validate cleaning effectiveness.

Best Practices for Manual Cleaning

Some recommended best practices for manual stencil cleaning:

  • Always use lint-free gloves to prevent fingerprints on stencil.
  • Apply just enough solvent using swabs/wipes to maximize cleaning without waste.
  • Frequently replace swabs, brushes and wipes to avoid spreading contamination.
  • Use unidirectional wipes in the direction of stencil tensioning.
  • Avoid excessive brushing or scrubbing to prevent damage to stencil surface.
  • Clean apertures before cleaning stencil surface to avoid redepositing contamination.
  • Allow sufficient drying time before reusing stencil after cleaning.
  • Maintain a separate cleaning area to prevent solvent contamination in production area.

Effect of Cleaning on Print Quality

Proper manual cleaning of stencils improves solder paste printing by:

  • Preventing insufficient paste deposits due to clogged apertures.
  • Eliminating solder balls caused by dried paste particles on stencil.
  • Removing other contaminants that affect wetting and release of paste.
  • Improving print definition by clearing apertures edges.
  • Allowing consistent volume and shape of paste deposits.
  • Reducing frequency of printing defects.
  • Increasing process control and stability.
  • Maximizing stencil life by preventing damage.

Conclusion

Manual cleaning is an economical yet effective method for cleaning stencils during prototype runs or low volume SMT production. Using the right technique along with suitable solvents, swabs and wipes allows removing paste residues without damaging the stencil. This improves paste transfer consistency and avoids print defects related to contaminated stencils. With appropriate cleaning frequency and effective inspection, stencil life can be increased considerably. Thus, following the proper protocol for manual cleaning is critical for any facility involved in SMT PCB assembly.

FAQs

Q1. How is manual stencil cleaning different from ultrasonic cleaning?

Manual cleaning relies on mechanical force applied through wipes, squeegees etc. along with solvents to remove paste. Ultrasonic cleaning uses high frequency sound waves and solutions to dissolve contaminants.

Q2. What solvents are used for manual stencil cleaning?

Common solvents like isopropyl alcohol, acetone and ethanol are used. Semi-aqueous solvents are also available. Solvent must be compatible with solder paste flux chemistry.

Q3. What causes solder balls during SMT assembly?

Residual solder paste particles left on stencil due to insufficient cleaning get dislodged and transferred on PCB during printing. These particles later form solder balls.

Q4. How does stencil cleaning affect process yield?

Insufficient stencil cleaning directly contributes to solder paste printing defects which lower process yield. Cleaning improves paste transfer efficiency.

Q5. When should stencil apertures be brushed during cleaning?

Apertures should be brushed first before cleaning the stencil surface. This allows dislodged residues to be removed from stencil surface rather than re-enter apertures.