rayming logo
Quote

Full understanding PCB X-Ray Inspection

The X-ray inspection is part of the process control in our quality management system, Not only detect issues in SMT, but the analysis of an X-Ray image can help to determine the root cause of a given defect, such as insufficient solder paste, skewed part placement, or improper reflow soldering profile.

AOI Testing
Electronic test
Flying Probe Test
ICT Test
Multilayer PCB
Prototype Assembly

To guarantee the optimal performance of electronic devices, X-ray inspection is conducted on PCBs at every stage of the assembly process. Since various categories of circuit boards adhere to different inspection standards, X-ray inspection has become a widely utilized technique. It is particularly effective in identifying defects that are invisible to the naked eye, ensuring higher quality and reliability.

What is PCB X-ray Inspection?

pcb x ray inspection

PCB x ray inspection is a sophisticated quality control technique used in the electronics manufacturing industry to examine the internal structures of printed circuit boards. This non-destructive testing method employs x-rays to create images of a PCB’s layers, components, and solder joints, allowing inspectors to identify defects, manufacturing errors, and potential reliability issues without damaging the board.

X ray inspection is particularly valuable for examining:

  1. Multi-layer PCBs
  2. Ball Grid Array (BGA) components
  3. Hidden solder joints
  4. Through-hole connections
  5. Vias and microvias

The ability to see through the various layers of a PCB makes x ray inspection an indispensable tool in modern electronics manufacturing. It helps ensure the quality and reliability of complex electronic assemblies, from consumer electronics to mission-critical aerospace and medical devices.

How does the X-ray Inspection System Work?

To fully understand PCB x ray inspection, it’s essential to grasp the basic principles of how an x-ray inspection system operates. The process involves several key components and stages:

1. X-ray Tube/Generator

The heart of any x ray inspection system is the x-ray tube or generator. This component produces the x-rays that penetrate the PCB. Here’s how it works:

  • A high voltage is applied across a cathode and an anode within a vacuum tube.
  • The cathode emits electrons, which are accelerated towards the anode.
  • When the high-speed electrons strike the anode, they produce x-rays.
  • The energy and intensity of the x-rays can be adjusted by varying the voltage and current applied to the tube.

2. Sample Operation

The PCB being inspected (the sample) is positioned between the x-ray source and the detector. Depending on the system, either the sample or the x-ray source/detector assembly can be moved to capture images from different angles. This movement allows for:

  • Inspection of specific areas of interest on the PCB
  • Creation of 3D images through computed tomography (CT) in advanced systems
  • Examination of solder joints from various angles to detect defects

3. Detection System

After passing through the PCB, the x-rays are captured by a detection system. Modern x ray inspection machines typically use digital detectors, which offer several advantages:

  • High sensitivity for better image quality
  • Rapid image acquisition for faster inspection times
  • Direct digital output for easy integration with image processing software

The most common types of detectors used in PCB x ray inspection are:

  • Flat panel detectors
  • Image intensifiers coupled with high-resolution cameras

4. Image Processing

Once the x-ray image is captured by the detector, it undergoes sophisticated image processing to enhance its quality and facilitate analysis. This stage involves:

  • Contrast enhancement to make defects more visible
  • Noise reduction to improve image clarity
  • Image stitching for large PCBs that require multiple shots
  • Application of filters to highlight specific features or defects

Advanced x ray inspection systems may also incorporate artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning algorithms to automatically identify and classify defects.

5. Inspection and Analysis

With the processed images available, trained operators or automated systems can perform the actual inspection and analysis. This stage involves:

  • Examining solder joints for voids, bridges, or insufficient solder
  • Checking component placement and orientation
  • Inspecting through-hole connections and vias
  • Identifying manufacturing defects such as cracks or delamination

In automated systems, the inspection software can compare the x-ray images against predefined criteria or “golden sample” images to quickly identify deviations and potential defects.

6. Quality Control

The final stage of the x ray inspection process involves quality control decision-making based on the inspection results. This may include:

  • Classifying boards as pass or fail
  • Marking specific defects for repair or rework
  • Providing feedback to the manufacturing process to prevent recurring issues
  • Generating inspection reports for traceability and process improvement

By integrating x ray inspection into the quality control process, manufacturers can significantly improve the reliability and quality of their PCB assemblies.

Types of X-Ray Machines

X ray inspection systems come in various configurations to suit different manufacturing needs and PCB complexities. Let’s explore the main types of x-ray machines used in the electronics industry:

1. 2D X-ray Inspection

2D x ray inspection systems are the most common and cost-effective option for many PCB manufacturers. These systems provide a top-down view of the PCB, creating a single plane image.

Key features of 2D x ray inspection:

  • Suitable for basic PCB inspection tasks
  • Faster inspection times compared to 3D systems
  • Lower cost and easier to operate
  • Ideal for detecting issues like solder bridges, voids, and component misalignment

Limitations:

  • Cannot provide depth information
  • May miss defects in complex, multi-layer boards

2. 3D X-ray Inspection

3D x ray inspection systems, also known as computed tomography (CT) systems, offer a more comprehensive view of the PCB by creating three-dimensional images.

Advantages of 3D x ray inspection:

  • Provides detailed information about PCB layers and internal structures
  • Allows for virtual cross-sectioning without damaging the board
  • Ideal for complex, high-density PCBs and advanced packaging technologies
  • Better detection of hidden defects and issues in multi-layer boards

Considerations:

  • Higher cost compared to 2D systems
  • Longer inspection times
  • Requires more sophisticated software and operator training

3. Online Operation

Online x ray inspection systems are integrated directly into the production line, allowing for real-time inspection of PCBs as they’re manufactured.

Benefits of online operation:

  • Immediate feedback on manufacturing quality
  • Reduced handling and potential for damage
  • Increased throughput and efficiency
  • Ability to catch and correct issues early in the production process

Challenges:

  • Requires careful integration with existing production equipment
  • May require higher initial investment

4. Offline Operation

Offline x ray inspection systems are standalone units used for detailed analysis and quality control checks.

Advantages of offline operation:

  • More flexibility in inspection parameters and techniques
  • Allows for in-depth analysis of complex issues
  • Can be used for failure analysis and process improvement
  • Typically offers higher resolution and more advanced features

Considerations:

  • Requires additional handling of PCBs
  • May introduce delays in the production process

The choice between online and offline x ray inspection often depends on factors such as production volume, board complexity, and specific quality control requirements.

AXI vs. AOI

When it comes to PCB inspection, two technologies often come into comparison: Automated X-ray Inspection (AXI) and Automated Optical Inspection (AOI). While both serve the purpose of identifying defects in PCBs, they have distinct characteristics and applications.

Automated X-ray Inspection (AXI)

Strengths of AXI:

  • Can see through layers, ideal for multi-layer PCBs
  • Excellent for inspecting hidden solder joints (e.g., BGAs)
  • Detects internal defects like voids in solder joints
  • Non-destructive testing method

Limitations of AXI:

  • Higher cost compared to AOI
  • Slower inspection speed
  • Requires specialized training for operators
  • Limited in detecting certain surface defects

Automated Optical Inspection (AOI)

Advantages of AOI:

  • Faster inspection speeds
  • Lower cost compared to AXI
  • Excellent for detecting surface defects
  • Can inspect component placement and orientation

Limitations of AOI:

  • Cannot see through layers or inspect hidden joints
  • Limited in detecting internal defects
  • May have difficulty with certain component types (e.g., BGAs)

In many manufacturing environments, a combination of both AXI and AOI technologies is used to achieve comprehensive inspection coverage. AOI is often used for rapid inspection of surface-mount components and solder joints, while AXI is employed for critical areas or high-reliability products where internal inspection is crucial.

Difference between PCB X-ray and PCBA X-ray Inspection (PCB Assembly)

While both PCB x ray inspection and PCBA x ray inspection involve the use of x-ray technology, they focus on different aspects of the manufacturing process:

PCB X-ray Inspection

  • Focuses on the bare PCB before component assembly
  • Primarily examines the PCB’s internal structure
  • Checks for issues like:
    • Layer misalignment
    • Broken or shorted traces
    • Via and through-hole integrity
    • Delamination between layers
  • Typically performed by PCB manufacturers as part of their quality control process

PCBA X-ray Inspection (PCB Assembly)

  • Examines the PCB after components have been mounted and soldered
  • Focuses on solder joint quality and component placement
  • Checks for issues such as:
    • Solder voids
    • Insufficient solder
    • Solder bridges
    • Component misalignment
    • BGA connection issues
  • Usually performed by electronics manufacturers or contract manufacturers

While the underlying x-ray technology is similar, the specific inspection criteria, software algorithms, and analysis techniques may differ between PCB and PCBA x ray inspection processes.

X-ray Inspection Services at RayMing PCB

At RayMing PCB, we understand the critical role that x ray inspection plays in ensuring the quality and reliability of printed circuit boards. Our state-of-the-art x ray inspection services are designed to meet the most demanding requirements of modern electronics manufacturing.

Our X-ray Inspection Capabilities

  1. Advanced Equipment:

    • We utilize the latest 2D and 3D x ray inspection systems
    • Our equipment is regularly calibrated and maintained to ensure optimal performance

  2. Comprehensive Inspection:

    • We offer both PCB and PCBA x ray inspection services
    • Our trained technicians can detect a wide range of defects, from solder voids to layer misalignment

  3. High-Resolution Imaging:

    • Our systems provide high-resolution x-ray images for detailed analysis
    • We can perform virtual cross-sectioning for in-depth examination of multi-layer PCBs

  4. Customized Inspection Protocols:

    • We work closely with clients to develop inspection criteria tailored to their specific needs
    • Our flexible approach ensures that critical areas receive appropriate attention

  5. Rapid Turnaround:

    • We offer quick inspection services to minimize impact on production schedules
    • Our efficient processes ensure fast reporting of results

  6. Expert Analysis:

    • Our team of experienced technicians provides expert interpretation of x-ray images
    • We offer detailed reports with clear explanations of any identified issues

  7. Continuous Improvement:

    • We leverage inspection data to provide feedback for process improvement
    • Our services can help clients optimize their PCB design and manufacturing processes

Why Choose RayMing PCB for X-ray Inspection?

  1. Quality Assurance: Our rigorous x ray inspection processes help ensure the highest quality PCBs and PCBAs
  2. Cost-Effectiveness: By identifying issues early, we help clients avoid costly rework and field failures
  3. Flexibility: We can accommodate various board sizes, complexities, and production volumes
  4. Cutting-Edge Technology: Our investment in advanced x ray inspection equipment ensures top-tier inspection capabilities
  5. Expertise: Our team’s deep knowledge of PCB manufacturing and x ray inspection techniques provides valuable insights
  6. Confidentiality: We understand the sensitive nature of PCB designs and maintain strict confidentiality protocols